This book feels like "Potential Book" to me (like the potential man meme). I love the ideas, themes, and overall concepts Kuang is trying to convey but some of it falls kind of flat for me. I really wanted to absolutely love this book but there are just somethings I would have liked more if she did it differently. The pacing kind of annoyed me, i felt like we are going thriugh pages of hammering similar information through the device of flashbacks but going nowhere forwards in the moment. They spend more time slogging between courts than the courts themselves. And the flashbacks are good for developing the characters, however I feel like multiple flashbacks tell us the same thing. (See alice section)
[Spoilers start here]
I love love love the idea of a modern dantes inferno, traversing hell has always been an interesting and cool idea to me (i have a story idea with this premise). I think the idea of equating hell to academia is super interesting, the fact the courts are part of a campus had me so excited but i was disappointed by how this idea gets dropped after the first 2. I wanted to see unique interpretations of each courttt pride and desire were so good i was like how is she going to make greed into academic thing or wrath just to be shown its all desert/swamp 😭. And like i said before they linger more between courts than actually focus on them and ik the point is Alice/Peter's character growth but i still wanted to see a unique world.
[On Alice, minor spoilers]
Im sorry but for a good amount of the book i couldnt stand Alice and i know thats supposed to be the point but she was really irritating me for a good minute. She keeps iterating the same point, rhat she was clearly a victim but she wasnt a victim because shes "different" like the reveal later on in the book came a shock to me because of how much praise grimes is given from her throughout the whole story. I would have expected grimes to be a fucking creep but i also dont understand how alice could praise him over and over again in every single instance when thats what he did to her ontop of everything else. Theres a point where the excuses just feel reduntant and it was lowkey exhausting to read through. Peter was also a victim of grimes but was more tolerable, maybe because we're not in his head the way we are in Alice's head but it came off that he realized they were victims way before alice did. I do enjoy their chemistry but i feel like it was so short lived, so much potential and i wish kuang did more with them because it really gets ruined by the miscommunication trope i fucking hate the miscommunication trope 😭.
Tldr; i feel like there was alot of potential in the world building, i found alice annoying for a good chunk of the book, the pacing is a bit too slow for my tastes.
Tbh the book made me appreciate the movie so much more. If youre reading princess bride without having watched the movie i urge you to watch it. Goldman improves the story a whole lot. But its also alot more romanticsized (which isnt necessarily bad if you can remove yourself from some of the bullshit in the book)
Like westley and buttercup are sickening to me in this book like watching the movie i was like omg this is peak romance but in the book by the end they were giving me the ick. And i know its supposed to be satirical but i just got more enjoyment from the movies gaze of them.
Inigo and fezzik are the best part of the book, their backstory segments are cut from the movie but those were some of my favorite parts. I dont recall their adventure through the zoo being in the movie either which was another part i really enjoyed.
The banter between inigo, fezzik and vizzini is bar for bar the same and im happy he keeps all that and im sad there wasnt more bcs it was funny in the movie and funny in the book.
I didnt mind the authors notes only partially, i liked the ones where he would talk about when his father read him the story (which im assuming is why he keeps that as a framing device in the movie) especially the part where he gets upset about westley's death. But some of the shit he was saying made me cringe, i put up with most of it since it was short but then the explanation of buttercups baby came along and i was like holy yappppp. And he was weird as fuck about that one lady idk if that was supposed to be a joke or whar but that literally made me skip the rest of the explanation segment.
Buttercups baby is what made me completely realize morganstern was fake, oomf techystatic said they told me morganstern was fake but i forgor so when i was reading it i was like what the fuck.
I mean finding out the ancedotes and morganstern was fake makes me think maybe goldman isnt as much of an ass irl but he probably is. The shit about his son pmo.
Buttercups baby is straight up fanfiction to me that shit made no sense at alllll. Already said it but the inigo story was the only good part of that. I dont know if i could handle more chapters of that tbh im happy he only did one.
Free me from this hell, what the fuck just happened.
Do I want the dark academia quest badge? Is a little virtual skull worth this suffering? I can read a different book but ngl most of the ones I haven't read felt like this plot. We endure -_-.
For reference, I guess he just started messing with her in the library ... If it weren't for the quest and the fact I requested this, I would DNF
Sunshin3 commented...
Theres no sex scenes in piranesi