Post from the Yesteryear forum
bookbunny96 started reading...

Yesteryear
Caro Claire Burke
bookbunny96 wrote a review...
Writers & Lovers by Lily King is one of those quiet books that sneaks up on you. It doesn’t rely on dramatic twists or big sweeping moments, but instead finds its power in the small, ordinary rhythms of a life that feels painfully real. At its centre is Casey Peabody, a struggling writer in her early thirties who is grieving the loss of her mother, drowning in debt, working long hours as a waitress, and trying desperately to finish the novel she has spent years writing. She is exhausted, anxious, lonely, broke, and still somehow holding on to this fragile, stubborn belief that her creative life matters.
Oddly enough, some of my favourite parts of the book were the scenes where Casey is waitressing at The Iris, the upscale restaurant where she works. I loved reading about the behind-the-scenes mechanics of how a restaurant runs: the setting up of the dining room before guests arrive, the choreography of taking orders, serving, remembering tiny details, navigating chefs, handling difficult customers, and keeping everything moving while your body and mind are both running on fumes. There is something so immersive about these sections. King captures the sheer physicality and emotional labour of waitressing so well. It made me think about how demanding that job really is, and how much invisible effort goes into making a dining experience feel seamless for the people sitting at the table. One of my favourite glimpses into The Iris was Casey carefully setting up the outside deck area with candlelit tables, surrounded by greenery and flowers. It was such a small moment, but it stayed with me because it felt so vivid and tender.
The romantic conflict in the book also worked well for me because it wasn’t just about Casey choosing between two men. It felt more like she was choosing between two possible versions of herself. On one side, there is Silas, a young, unpublished writer like Casey, still unsettled, still figuring himself out, driving his lime green LeCar and carrying the same kind of uncertainty she does. On the other side is Oscar, a successful published author with book tours, a beautiful home, and two young sons. He represents stability, success, comfort, and perhaps the promise of being taken care of. Both men reflect different desires in Casey: the longing to be understood by someone in the same stage of struggle, and the longing to finally rest in something secure.
What made Casey so compelling to me was how much sadness and stress she was carrying while still trying to function. Her anxiety felt very real, especially the way she used her “clenching” regimen, moving up and down her body, trying to somehow manage the panic and tension inside her. Her difficulty sleeping, her financial stress, her grief, and her uncertainty about her future all made me feel deeply protective of her. I kept thinking, almost instinctively, that she needed someone to take care of her. But the beauty of the book is that it doesn’t reduce her to someone waiting to be rescued. Even in her most fragile moments, Casey is still working, still writing, still making choices, still trying.
The only section that slightly lost me was Caleb’s brief visit towards the end. For some reason, that part had me disengaging a bit, and I found myself skimming. I understood why his presence mattered in terms of family, grief, and Casey’s history, but emotionally it didn’t pull me in the same way the rest of the book did. It felt like it slowed the momentum for me rather than adding to it.
Overall, Writers & Lovers is exactly the kind of quiet read I tend to love. It doesn’t make a huge splash, but it speaks beautifully about the simple movements, pleasures, humiliations, and tragedies of daily life. It is about grief, work, money, writing, love, anxiety, and the strange persistence it takes to keep believing in yourself when life gives you very little reason to. Lily King’s technical writing is strong and observant, though not always as free-flowing or effortless as I personally prefer. Still, this book stayed with me. It felt intimate, thoughtful, and deeply human, a tender portrait of a woman trying to build a life, one shift, one sentence, and one small act of courage at a time.
bookbunny96 finished a book

Writers & Lovers
Lily King
bookbunny96 started reading...

Writers & Lovers
Lily King
bookbunny96 wrote a review...
I’m honestly so upset because My Husband’s Wife had so much potential. For the first 75% of this book, I was convinced it was heading straight for five stars. I was hooked almost immediately. It had that rare, all-consuming thriller quality where every time I put it down, I still couldn’t stop thinking about it. The intrigue was so strong, and Feeney did such a good job weaving the multiple POVs together in a way that kept me glued to the page. It reminded me of exactly why I love reading thrillers in the first place.
But then the last 25% happened, and that’s where it lost me. I love a good twist, but twists for the sake of twists do not automatically make a thriller better. At some point, the ending started to feel less clever and more chaotic. The plot became overly convenient, the character motivations stopped lining up with what had been built earlier, and the story asked for a level of suspended disbelief that I just couldn’t give it. It almost felt like the book had created this brilliant, addictive setup without fully knowing how it wanted to land the ending.
That said, I did have a lot of fun with this. It completely held my attention, and I think it would be a great book to pull someone out of a reading slump. I just wish the final stretch had trusted the strength of its own premise a little more instead of piling on twist after twist. What could have been a riveting, five-star conclusion ended up feeling like an overseasoned meal. If Feeney had just put the salt shaker down, this could have been incredible.
bookbunny96 finished a book

My Husband's Wife
Alice Feeney