avatar

criticalshayming

I’m a bookish 30, not a sourdough 30🫶🏽 Most likely immersive reading 📖🎧 Known to give recs in the wild (the local B&N)🤝

1662 points

0% overlap
Level 5
My Taste
Babel
The Never List
Sunrise on the Reaping
God of Fury
Losers: Part I (Losers, #1)
Reading...
These Violent Delights
0%

criticalshayming wrote a review...

4d
  • Tampa
    criticalshayming
    Aug 24, 2026
    Tampa
    3.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: 5.0Characters: 1.0Plot: 3.0Audiobook: 4.0
    🫪

    How does one even begin to explain the experience that is “Tampa”. After reading a few reviews of other people trying to find the words to express the feeling they have upon completion of this book, I’m convinced that you just have to approach it as honest as possible.

    So, the truth is, what the book sets out to accomplish by simply existing, it does pretty damn flawlessly. Alissa doesn’t really give you as a reader the opportunity to separate from what you are seeing unless you quite literally put the book down. There’s not one moment where you aren’t sitting as uncomfortable as you possibly can inside the mind of a predator. In a case like this, (whenever you see someone on the news in a similar situation) there are degrees of separation from what the person has done and what that person thinks about what they have done. Celeste is unapologetic in the vile nature of her actions. And you as a reader almost feel complicit by hearing exactly what she thinks about what she is doing because no matter what is happening in the world around her she can not (or will not) feel bad about what she wants.

    There’s not one single redeeming quality of any (and i mean ANY) character in this book. You will hate everyone in varying degrees. By the end of the book you will feel cheated of what you feel SHOULD have happened, but void of shock about what DOES happen. Because in cases like this, it is what happens. Which will have you question the system more than you probably already do.

    And I want to emphasize that this is a short read. Not even 200 pages. So you would think you could get through it easily in one sitting. (I did but only because I couldn’t imagine reading this over the course of days and I wanted to get it over with.) The reason it will take you longer to read this than the average less than 200 page book is because you have to subject yourself to the vulgarities in Celeste’s mind in tandem with the obscene and vile things she does in real life. Where in a normal circumstance, you can just judge the actions of a heinous person and not know what’s going on in their head. There is quite literally nowhere to hide in this situation.

    Here lies the conflict: How do you rate something like this in earnest without feeling guilty about the what it is you are saying with a star system? We all know that the higher something is rated, that’s our way of telling the author “Please give us more of this” or “the quality of this book is what we are missing in literature. please don’t stop writing.” Because I’m not going to act like this book isn’t in a technical sense a “good read” because based on my personal criteria for what makes a good book this is a five star read. So i did something that I never thought I’d ever do when it comes to reading. I did the math.

    Quality of this book: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Characters: ⭐️ Plot: ⭐️⭐️⭐️ Enjoyment: none Audiobook:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ ——————————- Overall: 2.6 rounded up to ⭐️⭐️⭐️

    Now, do I recommend this book? No, I don’t.

    Do I regret reading this book? Yes, I do.

    Should this be on anyone’s TBR? No, it shouldn’t.

    Will you question any and all people who have participated in this kind of crime and more than likely think about this book the next time you hear about it in the news? Yes, you will.

    Is it one of the best books I have read this year even though it made me EXTREMELY UNCOMFORTABLE on every level possible?

    Sighs Yea.

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • Post from the Tampa forum

    4d
  • Tampa
    THERES STILL SO MUCH LEFT OF THIS BOOK!! (page 105)

    everytime i think “oh it cant get any worse” WORSE JUST KEEPS SHOWING UP🥴🥴

    5
    comments 1
    Reply
  • Post from the Tampa forum

    5d
  • Tampa
    Jail…for everyone…immediately!!! (page 76)
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    5
    comments 1
    Reply
  • criticalshayming made progress on...

    5d
    Tampa

    Tampa

    Alissa Nutting

    100%
    0
    0
    Reply

    Post from the Tampa forum

    5d
  • Tampa
    there’s still so much of this book left😩 (page 37)

    I hate being in this woman’s brain so much…. I feel like I need to bathe in Purel hand sanitizer… maybe even bleach….

    4
    comments 1
    Reply
  • criticalshayming wrote a review...

    5d
  • Half His Age
    criticalshayming
    Aug 23, 2026
    Half His Age
    3.0
    Enjoyment: 2.0Quality: 2.5Characters: 2.5Plot: 3.0Audiobook: 2.5
    🥴
    🚩

    yea…i don’t know…

    one of the weirdest experiences reading i have had in a while. while im not a prude by any means, i found myself icking out quite a bit throughout the book. and yea i get it…its a “coming of age” tale of a “taboo” relationship. and it works (kinda). but between the very straight to the point language and the blunt vulgarity of it all combined with Jeanette’s narration in the audiobook, i don’t know it just didn’t land the way i expected.

    that being said it’s a quick read and it got me out of the slump i was in so if nothing else that happened.

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • Post from the Half His Age forum

    5d
  • Half His Age
    You know what i mean?

    the further i get into this book…the more i think this is the exact kind of book that “Sam” would write.

    6
    comments 1
    Reply
  • criticalshayming started reading...

    2w
    These Violent Delights

    These Violent Delights

    Micah Nemerever

    0
    0
    Reply

    criticalshayming made progress on...

    2w
    A Study in Drowning

    A Study in Drowning

    Ava Reid

    26%
    1
    0
    Reply

    criticalshayming commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    2w
  • Nudgeling
    Edited
    Unpopular book opinions

    I wonder: how do you feel about expressing your unpopular book opinions publicly?

    There are a good number of universally loved books that I just didn't get the hype for or outright disliked, but I tend to keep these opinions to myself in fear of backlash. Sometimes, I even start to wonder if I read the book 'wrong' somehow and toy with the idea of re-reading the book to give it a second shot (but I rarely do). At the same time, I really respect people who unapologetically express their opinions, unpopular or no. So my fears might not be well-founded at all. In private, I am wayyy more outwardly critical of media i consume in general than I am online lol. Something about the internet is terrifying.

    I'm curious about how other people feel about this. Where do you fall on the scale of hiding in silence or screaming to the masses?

    Edit: Also, feel free to use this post to express said unpopular opinion if you're willing :P

    67
    comments 142
    Reply
  • Post from the If We Were Villains forum

    2w
  • If We Were Villains
    So……what??
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    7
    comments 0
    Reply
  • criticalshayming wrote a review...

    2w
  • If We Were Villains
    criticalshayming
    Aug 10, 2026
    If We Were Villains
    4.0
    Enjoyment: 4.5Quality: 4.0Characters: 4.0Plot: 4.0Audiobook: 4.5
    🎭️
    🪝
    🤫

    what a wild twisted messy ass ride… 4.25/5

    2
    comments 0
    Reply