eminesque earned a badge

Summer 2026 Readalong
Read at least 1 book in the Summer 2026 Readalong.
eminesque commented on a post
People really believe that whatever a guy who calls himself "Humbert Humbert" is saying about a 13 year old child and her deeds is true huh? There is not a single thing in this man that's honest.
Post from the Lolita forum
People really believe that whatever a guy who calls himself "Humbert Humbert" is saying about a 13 year old child and her deeds is true huh? There is not a single thing in this man that's honest.
eminesque started reading...

Lolita
Vladimir Nabokov
eminesque commented on a post
As someone who consumed way too much true crime way too young this intrigued me. After reading the first (and most horrific first twenty pages) I am delighted to see that it digs at true crime etc. The writing has already sucked me in and I think I'm going to enjoy this a lot.
Post from the The Kind Worth Killing forum
eminesque started reading...

The Kind Worth Killing
Peter Swanson
eminesque wrote a review...
Reads more like a history book than a novel, and does not take a stand on the morality of the people it's talking about. The prose is nothing to write home about and the story, though interesting from a humanist perspective, is too fragmented and lost in itself. The two halves connecting two timelines do not make sense existing together in the same book. The only value this book had for me was the historical aspect, for which it has the rating as seen.
eminesque finished a book

The Maniac
Benjamín Labatut
Post from the The Maniac forum
if Neumann was alive today he'd totally be a doomsday cult AI bro trying to sell me a new future
eminesque commented on a post
Its these kind of Books that make me feel pathetic in my capability of achieving something big, like all these scientists were somehow born wise and I was already losing the day I was concieved.
Post from the The Maniac forum
Its these kind of Books that make me feel pathetic in my capability of achieving something big, like all these scientists were somehow born wise and I was already losing the day I was concieved.
eminesque started reading...

The Maniac
Benjamín Labatut
eminesque commented on a post
eminesque commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Hello, all!
I just finished watching "Book reviews are gaslighting us" by Below the Fray on youtube. The central thesis of the video essay revolves around the soulless platitudes in most modern litcrit columns in newspapers and magazines. He brings up a lot of great points, and it made me think about non-monetized book reviews like those here on Pagebound.
My biggest question for you all is do you read (and/or write) negative reviews? I recently started writing negative reviews but have a bad habit of kneecapping my sentences and coddling the author more than I probably should. I am a firm believer that reviews are for readers and criticism is for the authors, though where exactly else are these authors to get criticism from if most modern litcrit is monetized and a bad review could get you fired or blacklisted?
As readers, do you enjoy reading a bad review? Do you seek out alternative, often negative opinions of books you enjoy? Do you feel vindicated by a bad review on a book you hated? What kind of review gets you to read a book most: a raving 5 star or a critical 1 star review that piques your interest?
TL;DR Do you read negative reviews of books (whether you've read them or not), and what do you feel the purpose of a review on a platform like PB is, exactly?
Signed, a ranty reader lol
eminesque is interested in reading...

Housekeeping
Marilynne Robinson
eminesque commented on eminesque's review of Flowers for Algernon
Indifferent.