avatar

horseheaux

horse girl 1st, book worm 2nd

759 points

0% overlap
Classics Starter Pack Vol I
Level 4
Literary Fiction Starter Pack Vol I
My Taste
The Wall
Giovanni's Room
On Strike Against God
Whereabouts
Biography of X
Reading...
Sky Daddy

horseheaux commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

2d
  • Does anyone else have an issue with the quality of the writing in a lot of books?

    Something I’ve noticed, especially since I started spending time in bookish spaces (booktok, bookstagram, etc.), is that my standards for books don’t really seem to align with most people’s. I DNF a LOT of books, and the most common reason why is that the quality of the writing isn’t good enough in my opinion. From what I’ve seen though, writing quality seems to be a fairly low priority for a lot of readers. Like, a lot of people seem to value other things more (which is fine), so much so that they’re willing to look past poor writing. For me, no matter how interesting a premise is, or how juicy a plot seems, or how likeable the characters seem like they’ll be, I can’t look past poor writing (spelling/grammar issues, repetition, inconsistencies/plot holes, etc.). I feel like people rarely ever mention writing quality in their reviews though! Even when I check the negative reviews, I feel like it’s rare for people to attribute their dislike to the writing quality. It kinda makes me feel a little crazy. Like no one else is seeing what I’m seeing, or like I’m overly critical, but at the same time, if I were truly overly critical I wouldn’t have ANY books that I like, but I do.

    Anyways, I’m not sure if I properly expressed what I’m trying to say, but does anyone have any thoughts?

    47
    comments 91
    Reply
  • horseheaux commented on horseheaux's review of Shy Girl

    2d
  • Shy Girl
    horseheaux
    Jul 24, 2025
    1.0
    Enjoyment: 0.5Quality: 0.5Characters: 0.5Plot: 2.0
    🙅‍♀️
    🐕
    🚫

    i am so sorry but what did i just read. this book needed some HEAVY editing before being published. grammar mistakes all over the place. the pacing was trash. nothing was fleshed out. ALSO THE ARTWORK WAS STOLEN FROM WHYN LEWIS. i did not buy any part of this. his dog for SEVEN years? be so fucking for real. 2 stars for the plot because it had potential to be good as a short story or as a deep dive into the psychological and physical transformation but unfortunately it was neither of those so it was a big fat miss for me. just 214 pgs of what felt like a half baked idea. (w)oof. misled yet again by a beautiful cover!!

    edit: did a google search and found a reddit post about this book. people think AI wrote it bc it is so bad and had awful formatting, repetitive phrasing, on top of the other reasons i also mentioned above. someone even put it into an AI text detector and it said it was highly confident it was AI generated. you cannot make this shit up (unless you're AI)

    2
    comments 2
    Reply
  • horseheaux started reading...

    3d
    Sky Daddy

    Sky Daddy

    Kate Folk

    1
    0
    Reply

    horseheaux finished reading and wrote a review...

    3d
  • It Lasts Forever and Then It's Over
    horseheaux
    Oct 12, 2025
    3.0
    Enjoyment: 2.0Quality: 4.0Characters: 3.5Plot: 3.0

    literary broccoli. or i guess maybe brussel sprouts bc i actually really enjoy broccoli. which is to say this book takes a lot of chewing and digesting and is good for you, but sometimes the experience itself isn’t pleasant. oh and i will say a very apt book for spooky season and darkening days

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • horseheaux commented on horseheaux's review of Ex-Wife

    5d
  • Ex-Wife
    horseheaux
    Oct 10, 2025
    5.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 4.5Plot: 5.0

    babe wake up new favorite book just dropped!! love and loss and a whirlwind of hedonism. delightful!

    so many good lines in here but here are some fave excerpts:

    "i wished that heaven were real to me, and wondered why it was not, to me or any contemporaries i knew. the victorians had been able to leave things to god - or the next generation. but the sound of guns and the knowledge of the immediacy of death and the desire to live as swiftly as possible, in the little time that youth and capacity to live swiftly, lasted - had got between that next generation and any whisperings of angels. perhaps that was it - it did not matter why, really - we had to get on without heaven as best we could."

    "i wondered what he was thinking, and i thought, 'it is not true that in time, one 'gets over' almost anything. in time, one survives almost anything."

    "and some absurd remnant of belief in miracles curled up and died in me, almost painlessly." (oof, what a zinger)

    5
    comments 3
    Reply
  • horseheaux commented on alexandriaslibrary's review of Ex-Wife

    5d
  • Ex-Wife
    alexandriaslibrary
    Oct 04, 2025
    5.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    A new all-time favorite!! I am so grateful for McNallys for republishing this classic, and for Ursula Parrott to document the experiences of a modern woman nearly 100 years ago.

    Patricia, 24, finds herself alone after her husband decides their progressive marriage is /too/ much for him. She now must learn what it means to be an Ex-Wife (her and her crew of divorcees muse “An ex-wife is a young woman for whom the eternity promised in the marriage ceremony is reduced to three years or five or eight.”)

    So charming, charismatic, and heartbreaking, Patricia is a beacon in the canon of “Sad Girl Lit”.

    The ending stirred similar emotions as “My Antonia” did (another all-time fav) and I ended up crying at the end. Brilliant til the end, what a gem

    3
    comments 1
    Reply
  • horseheaux finished reading and wrote a review...

    5d
  • Ex-Wife
    horseheaux
    Oct 10, 2025
    5.0
    Enjoyment: 5.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 4.5Plot: 5.0

    babe wake up new favorite book just dropped!! love and loss and a whirlwind of hedonism. delightful!

    so many good lines in here but here are some fave excerpts:

    "i wished that heaven were real to me, and wondered why it was not, to me or any contemporaries i knew. the victorians had been able to leave things to god - or the next generation. but the sound of guns and the knowledge of the immediacy of death and the desire to live as swiftly as possible, in the little time that youth and capacity to live swiftly, lasted - had got between that next generation and any whisperings of angels. perhaps that was it - it did not matter why, really - we had to get on without heaven as best we could."

    "i wondered what he was thinking, and i thought, 'it is not true that in time, one 'gets over' almost anything. in time, one survives almost anything."

    "and some absurd remnant of belief in miracles curled up and died in me, almost painlessly." (oof, what a zinger)

    5
    comments 3
    Reply
  • horseheaux commented on cowboyfanclub's review of The Country Will Bring Us No Peace

    1w
  • The Country Will Bring Us No Peace
    cowboyfanclub
    Oct 01, 2025
    1.5
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    literally who disappears in this book. stop saying the birds stopped singing and people are disappearing if no one disappears. 

    1
    comments 1
    Reply
  • horseheaux wrote a review...

    1w
  • The Country Will Bring Us No Peace
    horseheaux
    Oct 07, 2025
    3.5
    Enjoyment: 3.5Quality: 3.5Characters: 3.5Plot: 3.5
    📡

    okay read it in one day and i liked it but i wanted more on the antenna!!

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • horseheaux commented on a post

    1w
  • Shy Girl
    Thoughts from 0% (page 1)

    is there a more beautiful book cover out there? probably not

    6
    comments 3
    Reply
  • horseheaux commented on a post

    1w
  • Shy Girl
    Thoughts from 0% (page 1)

    is there a more beautiful book cover out there? probably not

    6
    comments 3
    Reply
  • horseheaux started reading...

    2w
    It Lasts Forever and Then It's Over

    It Lasts Forever and Then It's Over

    Anne de Marcken

    3
    1
    Reply

    horseheaux finished reading and wrote a review...

    2w
  • Flush
    horseheaux
    Sep 27, 2025
    4.0
    Enjoyment: 3.5Quality: 4.0Characters: 4.0Plot: 3.5

    i love you flush!! i love the relationship we have with dogs!! i miss my dog 😭😭

    1
    comments 0
    Reply
  • horseheaux completed their yearly reading goal of 50 books!

    2w

    horseheaux's 2025 Reading Challenge

    53 of 50 read
    On Strike Against God
    Modern Nature
    Hunchback
    The Post-Office Girl
    We Both Laughed in Pleasure: The Selected Diaries of Lou Sullivan
    Perfume: The Story of a Murderer
    I Await the Devil's Coming
    1
    0
    Reply