morbidmuse commented on morbidmuse's review of A Court of Thorns and Roses (A Court of Thorns and Roses #1)
I’ll be honest, I hate-read this. I loved hate-reading this and making my husband listen to every stupid detail. But I would not wish it upon my enemy (maybe my worst).
morbidmuse left a rating...
morbidmuse wrote a review...
I’ll be honest, I hate-read this. I loved hate-reading this and making my husband listen to every stupid detail. But I would not wish it upon my enemy (maybe my worst).
Post from the Dragonfly in Amber (Outlander, #2) forum
morbidmuse started reading...

Dragonfly in Amber (Outlander, #2)
Diana Gabaldon
morbidmuse entered a giveaway...
morbidmuse left a rating...
morbidmuse finished a book

Outlander (Outlander, #1)
Diana Gabaldon
morbidmuse paused reading...

A Short History of the World in 50 Lies
Natasha Tidd
morbidmuse commented on a post
Sadly and respectfully, I probably won’t be finishing this one for a couple reasons.
I’m not the right reader to fully appreciate Kimmerer’s message in its delivered form. Gift economy was something I studied during my undergraduate and found fascinating. It did change my outlook of the world—in the same way I think Kimmerer is attempting to do with this book. So/but…
I already agree. I already feel that hope and that wish to appreciate the world, the Earth, the fellow human, for what it is and not what it can provide for me.
Because I already agree, I find myself reading this with a system-making mind rather than a meaning-making mind; I find myself nitpicking her optimism and becoming pedantic. (For example, Kimmerer talks of the serviceberries being a gift that required no coercion or labour and, embarrassingly enough, I found myself arguing that Paulie and Ed intentionally planted those trees, specifically because they produced better and more abundant berries than the native species, in land that they have farmed and cultivated for who knows how long).
That’s not the point Kimmerer is trying to make. I don’t think she’s trying to produce airtight anecdotes and make an argument. I think she’s just trying to share knowledge and introduce the idea to others. And it feels cruel to continue reading this when I’m too rigid to receive that message.
Post from the The Serviceberry: Abundance and Reciprocity in the Natural World forum
Sadly and respectfully, I probably won’t be finishing this one for a couple reasons.
I’m not the right reader to fully appreciate Kimmerer’s message in its delivered form. Gift economy was something I studied during my undergraduate and found fascinating. It did change my outlook of the world—in the same way I think Kimmerer is attempting to do with this book. So/but…
I already agree. I already feel that hope and that wish to appreciate the world, the Earth, the fellow human, for what it is and not what it can provide for me.
Because I already agree, I find myself reading this with a system-making mind rather than a meaning-making mind; I find myself nitpicking her optimism and becoming pedantic. (For example, Kimmerer talks of the serviceberries being a gift that required no coercion or labour and, embarrassingly enough, I found myself arguing that Paulie and Ed intentionally planted those trees, specifically because they produced better and more abundant berries than the native species, in land that they have farmed and cultivated for who knows how long).
That’s not the point Kimmerer is trying to make. I don’t think she’s trying to produce airtight anecdotes and make an argument. I think she’s just trying to share knowledge and introduce the idea to others. And it feels cruel to continue reading this when I’m too rigid to receive that message.
morbidmuse made progress on...
morbidmuse DNF'd a book

The Serviceberry: Abundance and Reciprocity in the Natural World
Robin Wall Kimmerer