Post from the Frankenstein forum
nakedmollrat commented on Megantje's review of Frankenstein
Still have no words
nakedmollrat commented on a post
nakedmollrat commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
This might be a slightly hot take Iâm not sure. But I personally almost never like a movie adaptation of books I read, and itâs even worse when I loved the book. The adaptation completely ruins the book for me and itâs devastating. (Even though I know this about myself, I always watch the movie, I like to create my own suffering.)
So my theory, or resolution, to this problem is that people should only make movie adaptations for books that are generally reviewed as less than 4 stars. An EH book is the perfect book to take and build into a better movie. If the book is 4 stars or above, maybe donât touch it. đĽ¸đŤŁđŤŁđŤŁ
Thoughts?
nakedmollrat commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I wonder if youâve ever encountered people who say they never read fiction because it has no application in life. Twice in my life I met such people. Their reasoning simply is that fiction is not real, made-up, so they wonât be able to use it in their lives. Therefore, they are not spending their time reading it. At the same time, they both like to read, one of them is a lawyer, another â an academic. They just only read books containing facts. I think itâs a very peculiar type of thinking. As someone who sees so much value in reading fiction, I think they are missing out on so much.
nakedmollrat commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Has anyone else got themselves out of a reading slump recently? I feel like I'm tearing through books this month after a period of literary boredom and it feels delightful đ¤
Post from the Pagebound Club forum
Has anyone else got themselves out of a reading slump recently? I feel like I'm tearing through books this month after a period of literary boredom and it feels delightful đ¤
nakedmollrat wrote a review...
I spent the majority of the book hugely enjoying it, I devoured it in a couple of days. But at the end I feel... unsatisfied. I'll weigh up what I most enjoyed and what I least enjoyed:
One of my favourite things about this book was the imagery. Atwood is absolutely expert with this and uses similes, metaphors, personification in the most creative but effective ways- not trying too hard, but hitting home. Despite the fact that I'm an English lit student, during my personal reads I don't usually find myself mentally noting every single good simile, but some of these I couldn't help thinking.. damn, that's so good!
Next what I loved or at least appreciated was the characterisation. Every single character that I can think of was morally grey, I could never decide whether to love or to hate them. They might do something super admirable one moment, then completely disappoint you the next, which I found so profoundly human.
As much as the fragmented and extremely unreliable narration frustrated me, it was very brilliantly done.
Now for some minor issues I had. Disclaimer, I know that these are issues that are personal to me as a reader, and most of these were absolutely intentional by Atwood. I will say that this is an extremely clever book, but cleverness doesn't always constitute enjoyment.
Personally I struggle with ambiguous endings and whilst I found it clever I equally found it frustrating.
I also struggled to feel as immersed in the world of Gilead as I have with other dystopian worlds. The very nature of Offred having limited knowledge beyond her little sphere makes this the case. In terms of world building what I will say though is that, of course, it is scary how close to home it often felt. As of now the book reserves its timeless status.
Overall, I rated it a 3.5 stars, for a very clever book that I enjoyed most of the way through, but for reasons which I've attempted to unpack, the ending didn't satisfy me as much as some of my absolute favourite books have.
nakedmollrat finished a book

The Handmaidâs Tale (The Handmaid's Tale, #1)
Margaret Atwood
nakedmollrat made progress on...
nakedmollrat made progress on...
nakedmollrat left a rating...
I knew for most of this book that it would be a 5 star read for me and the ending confirmed this. I haven't felt as stunned finishing a book for a long time. For one, something about Mary Shelley's writing style which I can't quite pin down felt so satisfying to me, somewhere in the rich language and the flow of it all. Not to mention the fact that this book goes to town on my favourite literary themes of all time: gender, nature and religion. I could write dissertation level waffle right now and unpack everything but I'll keep it short because I can't even begin to do it justice.
nakedmollrat finished a book
Frankenstein
Mary Wollstonecraft Shelley
Post from the Frankenstein forum
Post from the Frankenstein forum
Something about the way she writes just hits, the sentence flow feels perfectly matched with the pace of my brain. Plus the fact that there's a beautiful quote about once every 2 pages.
nakedmollrat commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I feel that I might be the nicest rater in the world and basically never rate anything less than 3 stars. Sometimes I go back as if to edit my rating down and then stop myself! I genuinely feel that I enjoy almost every book I read but maybe this is because a) I know what I like and b) I will DNF if I don't like something. But everyone lmk what your criteria are when rating a book!!
Post from the Pagebound Club forum
I feel that I might be the nicest rater in the world and basically never rate anything less than 3 stars. Sometimes I go back as if to edit my rating down and then stop myself! I genuinely feel that I enjoy almost every book I read but maybe this is because a) I know what I like and b) I will DNF if I don't like something. But everyone lmk what your criteria are when rating a book!!
nakedmollrat commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
A day late but here we are!!! You know the drill, whatâs a complaint (no matter how big, small, silly, dramatic, etc) you need to shout to the void?!