snaggletoothd commented on a post
Maybe bcause I'm traveling right now, but I have read this like a dozen times and I don't understand. Someone help đ Long quote:
"In 2010, while driving on the highway, I listened to a fascinating episode of the NPR show Radiolab, called âWords.â The hosts described how the use of wordsâassociating things with namesâallows us to perceive the world in a completely different way than if we did not have words. They describe an experiment in which rats are placed in an all-white room with food hidden in one of the corners. The rat sees the food, but, before it can reach it, the experimenters spin the rat or otherwise make it disoriented enough to not remember which corner has the food. What the experimenters found is that the rats, in picking which corner to approach, approached each corner an equal number of timesâin other words, it had a 25 percent chance of choosing the correct corner. When the experiment is repeated with one of the walls painted blue and the food always placed in the left-hand corner of the blue wall, the wall can then serve as a ânavigational cueâ to help the rats understand where the food is. But even with this new blue wall, the rats still only guess the correct corner 25 percent of the time. While rats can recognize blue as a distinct color and left as a distinct direction, they cannot piece these two bits of information together. âLeft of the blue wallâ is impossible for rats to grasp. In a similar experiment, children up to the age of six will behave as the rats did, likely because their spatial awareness (essentially the idea of prepositionsââof,â âunder,â âon,â âthrough,â etc.) takes that long to develop. This experiment suggests that the use of words and the context they provide fundamentally changes how we can literally see the world. When one interviewer asked, âWhat is thought without language?â the other replied, âWell, I donât think itâs very much at all.â The use of words to name things gives our world shape, depth, and perspective. Those who can speak or understand a language are inheriting with it the ability to see the world in a unique way, fundamentally informed by that culture. Different cultures will carry different contextsâas such, different languages will offer different perspectives and ways of seeing the world. There is a vast system of meaning, interpreting, and perceiving particular to each culture and language. Every language tells a different story."
The bold line is where my question comes in. How does an experiment about visual data using a critter we don't speak the language of show that words contextualize visual input? Like, I for sure agree with the overall point we are trying to make here but I cannot grasp why we are using rat eyeballs to make it?? When humans develop enough to be able to conceptualize left of blue are we saying that's because of language, which rats never develop thus left of blue never makes sense to them?
snaggletoothd made progress on...
snaggletoothd is interested in reading...

That Which Feeds Us: A Hawaiian Gothic
Keala Kendall
snaggletoothd is interested in reading...

Scapegoat: What the Invasive Species Story Gets Wrong
Clare Follmann
snaggletoothd commented on a List
Bro Fiction
These books are âEat Prey Loveâ for men in their twenties.
All in good fun, I love many books on this list so please donât shy away from (some of) these recs!
29






snaggletoothd is interested in reading...

Major Labels: A History of Popular Music in Seven Genres
Kelefa Sanneh
snaggletoothd is interested in reading...

Undocumented: How Immigration Became Illegal
Aviva Chomsky
snaggletoothd made progress on...
snaggletoothd commented on a post
snaggletoothd commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I've seen a few people mention that they, like me, use audiobooks as a way to motivate themselves into chores! So I got curious: what's your chore of choice with an audiobook?
I definitely have mixed results! I like laundry best, since it is pretty mindless and I'm able to focus on the book. Dishwashing by hand is alright for this, but I do have to compete with water noises - and I find that for deep cleaning or organizing, I can sometimes space out and miss things.
Would love to hear what you guys like to do around the house while you listen đ§š đ§
Post from the Pagebound Club forum
I've seen a few people mention that they, like me, use audiobooks as a way to motivate themselves into chores! So I got curious: what's your chore of choice with an audiobook?
I definitely have mixed results! I like laundry best, since it is pretty mindless and I'm able to focus on the book. Dishwashing by hand is alright for this, but I do have to compete with water noises - and I find that for deep cleaning or organizing, I can sometimes space out and miss things.
Would love to hear what you guys like to do around the house while you listen đ§š đ§
snaggletoothd commented on Sherryy's update
snaggletoothd made progress on...
snaggletoothd started reading...

Dungeon Crawler Carl (Dungeon Crawler Carl, #1)
Matt Dinniman
snaggletoothd commented on snaggletoothd's update
snaggletoothd is re-reading...

The Long Game (Game Changers, #6)
Rachel Reid
snaggletoothd is re-reading...

The Long Game (Game Changers, #6)
Rachel Reid
snaggletoothd finished a book

Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West (The Wicked Years, #1)
Gregory Maguire
snaggletoothd commented on dandelions.n.wolves's update