I know the storing a human mind trope is very common in scifi but I’m just a sucker for it. I really enjoyed this one, and I think it had one of the most developed/engaging leads. To start with, the idea of a mind-upload as a cemetery substitute is fascinating. I liked the contrast of Jimin learning more about her mother through an entity that both is and isn’t her mother. I also think this story continues discussions on grief and depression that have been discussed earlier in the story right before, The Materiality of Emotions. In that one we were exploring why people tend to hold on to their pain and why they feel a need to have tangible proof of their emotions. In this story, the posthumous mind-uploadings serve in some ways, as that very proof, especially when a majority of people treat the Minds as real people. I enjoyed the discussion on whether the archived mind is the actual person or if it simply is a simulation.
I’m also fascinated by the idea that these places where people can visit Minds are called libraries, and that they have replaced libraries as we know them today. I definitely think that says something about the society in which this story is set in, but also contemporary society, a commentary on how digital technology has replaced records and physical books. It actually reminds me of the recent news on how AI companies are digitizing and destroying rare physical books. There’s also this idea we are playing with here of digital permanence; this guarantee of the things we’ve saved still being there because it’s uploaded on this server only to find it missing. What happens when we start forgetting memories or people we once knew? I need to reflect on this a bit more.
The heart of this story is Jimin’s complicated relationship to motherhood, both her own impeding motherhood but also her rocky relationship with her own mother. I thought this was so well done. This technology allows her to have some type of connection to Eunha that she never had growing up. In a way, it’s really like what that discussion program mentioned, that “the archived Mind helps us understand the people who have gone before us.” She has the same fears her mother had, of disconnect and losing herself. Jimin fears she’ll turn out like her mother, neglectful and resentful towards her own child. Eunha’s missing records in the index represent how she was lost in the world. She’s adrift just like her own data, which is ironic because the whole point of this endeavor is to anchor the mind of the person. She lost her own identity and sense of self when she became a mother, and coupled with postpartum depression and lack of support, couldn’t be there for herself or children. I think she felt no one ever understood her and she struggled deeply with that her entire life and unfortunately took it out on Jimin. But actually now that I think about it, it's interesting that it’s the physical books and belongings of her mother, and not this simulation, that led Jimin to understand Eunha and her past. If she hadn’t found the physical books she wouldn’t have even been able to locate her mother’s data. So maybe also it’s a message that technology really gets in the way of human connection. What happens when one’s existence is reduced to recorded data points?