Loyaute commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I've been hesitating to post reviews in here because I think my thoughts are too scattered to make it cohesive. In a way, I think reviews can be an artform, and I never feel I can do them justice.
Do you think about reviews this way? Do you put a lot of time into them or do you keep it simple?
Loyaute commented on LillianFrost's update
LillianFrost is interested in reading...

The Escape (Horses of the Dawn, #1)
Kathryn Lasky
Loyaute commented on keyaunna's review of The Everlasting
after hearing so so much hype surrounding this book, i was very much looking forward to reading it. the beginning chapter brought so much promise, and i was immediately hyped to get into it. however, as the book went on, it felt like a repetitive drag with little to no character development and a romance that i just very much disliked. owen mallory, as a protagonist, is very bare-bones. but also, he was so uninteresting for me. in the beginning of the book, he showed very incel vibes and i heard that he gets better in the book but like... where? he continues to be obsessed with the idea of una everlasting for the entirety of the book, even after he realizes the person behind its events. furthermore, he's so centrist throughout the whole book. even under a fascist dictatorship, he is still making excuses. like boy. if you don't have character development now i'm gonna lose it. we find out the villain so early in the story too that the story just feels like it wants to get itself over with.
una, as a character, was so boring for me as well. it felt like all she was in the story for was to be the love interest. like that's it. she had little depth about her. additionally, the time travel portions of the book were the most boring and repetitive drivel i've read in a while. there is no reason why i need to read the exact same events over and over and over again and have it pushed to me that something is changing. i got tired after the third one tee bee aytch. i really wish i liked this book more, but i dove in too quickly to the hype and was disappointed.
Loyaute commented on BeauRegardsBones's update
BeauRegardsBones earned a badge

Tiny but Mighty Nonfiction
Champion: Finished 5 Side Quest books.
Loyaute commented on acidicchaos's review of The Picture of Dorian Gray
While I loathed Dorian Gray, I absolutely loved The Picture of Dorian Gray. I found it absolutely delicious! It's elegant on its surface and then ruthlessly dark underneath.
What This Book Does Well What fascinated me most was how Wilde constructs the novel almost as a moral experiment. Dorian was not designed for sympathy - he was designed for observation. We are invited to watch what happens when beauty, vanity, privilege, and influence are left entirely unchecked.
There is a cold clarity to his descent into an almost mathematically inevitable demise. I felt like every choice Wilde made was deliberate, and for such a short novel, he didn't rush the unravelling.
I loved the triangle of characters, and to be honest, I think I would have to do another read through to fully formulate my thoughts, but it was clear that each man represented different moral and philosophical postures.
As a symbolism girlie, the symbolism here is masterful! I'm excited to do another read through in the future to track down all of the symbolism woven in and what I think it means.
Where It Could Short For Some The prose is stylistically dense and some of the dialogue does not have tags, which can make it a bit confusing at points.
The only other slight limitation could be the emotional inaccessibility of the characters. At no point did I really find myself sympathetic to Dorian, but personally, I don't think we were meant to.
Writing Quality & Craft To me, The Picture of Dorian Gray is a gothic psychological study in the form of a moral allegory. The writing itself is exquisite. I think what makes this book still relevant today is its clarity of moral architecture. It does not soften or excuse Dorain. It does not invite the reader to rationalize his self-worship. Instead, it allows us to view all of Dorian's choices until the ending feels morally satisfying.
Final Thoughts While I don't have a good thesis at this point, I was intellectually riveted throughout the book, and I'm excited to go back through it and formulate my own thoughts on the symbolism and philosophical aspects of the novel.
Who I Would Recommend This To Readers who enjoy symbolic, allegorical fiction, appreciate philosophical/psychological studies, and, of course, anyone who loves gothic literature!
Scoring Breakdown 5's all the way down (Personal Enjoyment, Execution (did the book do what it set out to do?), writing & craft quality, characters, plot
Loyaute commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
What's one thing you learned this week from your reading? It can be a fact, a random curiosity, a beautiful line, or even something you realized about yourself! My Tidbit: Intentional slow reading is changing how I approach other books too. I started a fantasy novel I hated and wanted to DNF, but I slowed down to the point that I actually reread the opening chapters and found little flakes of gold under the mess. Still up in the air if I'll actually like the book, but I'm glad I looked again.
As for some Pagebound related trivia: I'm reading Algospeak by Adam Aleksic and I learned about Sociolect, a form of language used by a particular social group (pg 31/247), so for us Boundlings it would be like our use of the word 'Yoink'! For those of you who have been on Pagebound longer than I have, I would love to hear some of the other popular sociolects that have been used!
Loyaute commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
If you could pack one suitcase and move into any fictional home immediately - where are you going?
Drafty castles absolutely count. So do crooked cottages, dramatic cliffside mansions, hobbit holes, chaotic city apartments, enchanted libraries, and suspiciously affordable small-town farmhouses.
Are you:
🌧️ Living your best moody life in a crumbling estate?
🌿 Baking bread in a cozy woodland cottage?
📚 Secretly hoping your house comes with hidden passageways and a mildly concerning attic?
🕯️ Choosing vibes over structural integrity?
Drop the book + the home + one reason you’d survive (or absolutely wouldn’t).
Bonus: what’s the first thing you’re decorating or rearranging when you move in?
Let’s see where PageBound is relocating.
Loyaute commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Anyone know best way to do formatting for quotes?
There is this
But I've found that the formatting on that is so incredibly broken and has 0 linewrap so it just floods out of the boxes and off the edge of the page lmao.
Loyaute commented on a List
Older Protagonist
Books where the protagonist is around or older than 50
11






Loyaute commented on a post
Okay I couldn't resist starting this immediately because it sounded sooo interesting and surprisingly from me (I do not like poetry at all), the structure of each of these is so cool that the only reason I'm stopping is that I'm supposed to do something else
Loyaute started reading...

Healing the Land Teaches Us Who We Are: How Indigenous Cultural Resistance Can Restore the Earth, Recover Community, and Create Sustainable Futures
PhD Maceo Carrillo Martinet
Loyaute commented on CoffeeWorld's update
CoffeeWorld started reading...

Bury My Heart Under the Martian Sky
Juan Manuel Perez
Loyaute wrote a review...
eARC via Interstellar Flight Press and NetGalley
I have never read "scifaiku" (my new favorite word) poetry before, so really didn't know what to expect with this. I was very pleasantly surprised, though! This was delightfully creative; I especially enjoyed the haiku crown form (sets of 7 haiku).
This collection falls under science fiction, but more specifically Indigenous Futurism and Chicano Futurismo. If you're interested in sci fic (even if you don't typically read poetry), I think you'd find something to love in this book! My specific favorite pieces were The Devil in the Woods: The Warning and Bury My Heart Under the Martian Sky.
Beyond the poetry, I also really appreciated the author's note at the end that explained this genre, style, and the poems. The author seemed very charismatic and I appreciated being able to read some pieces back with a new perspective.
If you're interested in a poem that "imagine[s] Godzilla attending a pow wow to 'smoke it up and chill' after 'messing up a place,'" then you'll want to check this one out😄 (But seriously, there are also pieces discussing colonialism, climate change, etc. It is a great balance of fun and serious.)
▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎▪︎ My review system ⭐️Very bad ⭐️⭐️Below average ⭐️⭐️⭐️Average ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Above average ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Extraordinary, special (Overall review=rough average of subcategories)
Loyaute finished a book

Bury My Heart Under the Martian Sky
Juan Manuel Perez
Loyaute commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
This question came to me as I was reading an old, used copy of The Turn of the Screw by Henry James. It is an old spanish edition, printed in 1971 by Salvat Editores and Alianza Editorial, that I bought second-hand with the pages almost falling off the spine (I only mention this because I renovated it myself and I'm quite proud of it 😌)
While I was reading, I noticed that there was a passage underlined in pencil. This is that quote (imagine this but in spanish lmao):
I learnt something – at first certainly – that had not been one of the teachings of my small smothered life; learnt to be amused, and even amusing, and not to think for the morrow.
This quote is something that I would not have ever remarked upon, if not for the fact that someone in the past thought that it was worthy of being highlighted, and it made me wonder: who highlighted this? A certain García Rojas signed their name on the first page of the book, along with "Madrid - 1 Marzo - 1976" in what looks like faded blue ink. Did they highlight the quote? Was it someone else before or after? And for whoever it was, what did that quote mean to them? Did they find it pretty and so decided to underline it, or did they somehow connect with it? What was the life they were living, if they felt a connection to this quote?
I decided to look for more (with a mighty care to not spoil myself), and I also found this quote highlighted:
I’ve been living with the miserable truth, and now it has only too much closed round me.
The english text invokes feelings of anxiety and fear, but in this spanish edition, "too much closed round me" is translated as defeated me, so the quote in spanish lends itself to be interpreted in a more anguished and sad way. How does this quote connect with the other one? What was the reason the reader felt so drawn to them? They were both underlined in pencil, so I assume they're both by the same person, but what if they aren't?
I love asking myself these questions because I love to think about the lives of the people whose hands have been in the same objects I have, and how their state of mind could've impacted their reading. I also love that there is no answer to them, I'm drawn to the endless possibilities of this insolvable mystery!
So my question for this post is: Have you ever found any highlighted or underlined quote in a second-hand book you bought, or took from a library? And if so, what was it? Did they leave any notes? Have you thought about why those quotes specifically affected a past reader of the same book? Do you have any theories?
I would love to know all of the quotes you guys have found!
Loyaute commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Happy Lunar New Year!
In honour of that. What is your favourite book from a country that celebrates Lunar New Year? Alternately who is your favourite fictional horse?