caterpillaronalog TBR'd a book

The Vanishing Cherry Blossom Bookshop
Takuya Asakura
caterpillaronalog entered a giveaway...
Post from the Chain-Gang All-Stars forum
caterpillaronalog TBR'd a book

I'm Thinking of Ending Things
Iain Reid
caterpillaronalog started reading...

To Be or Not To Be: A Chooseable-Path Adventure
Ryan North
caterpillaronalog is interested in reading...

Lapvona
Ottessa Moshfegh
caterpillaronalog started reading...

The Crucible: A Play in Four Acts
Arthur Miller
caterpillaronalog TBR'd a book

When We Lost Our Heads
Heather O'Neill
caterpillaronalog is interested in reading...

Les MisƩrables
Victor Hugo
Post from the Pagebound Club forum
hey everyone!!
so i've noticed a few things during discussions about characters in books, mainly on pagebound but also as well as in the wild and on social media. i have found that while it's very popular to like characters that are sort of "morally grey", especially in fantasy novels, there are a few guidelines they must follow. they have to be at least a little likeable, and a lot of that mainly revolves around their behaviour. how "bad" they are, how far their actions go to harm others.
for example: many characters who are written as "evil" but have a turning point sometime in a book or series don't commit acts that we would consider too evil. they're always things you can come back fromā insults, temporary harm, threats. and even with pure villains, when audiences like them, they're still more likely to simply have killed someone rather than be a serial torturer, or violent to groups of people, or partake in some huge betrayal.
obviously i don't think any of those options should be things that make a character likeable, but it got me thinking: is there a point we draw a line? what actions are deemed "acceptable" for an antagonist or villain to do where they can still be redeemed or liked by a general audience, and what is too far? i would have thought murder to be across the line, because that's one of the worst things you can do in real life, but in books it seems to be much different.
do you guys have any thoughts? what are your personal lines for when you find a character irredeemable?
caterpillaronalog started reading...

Wuthering Heights
Emily Brontƫ
caterpillaronalog commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
There's a radio show in the UK called Desert Island Discs. It's a bit of an institution and has been broadcasting since the 40s. The premise is as follows: Each week a guest, playfully referred to as a "castaway" during the programme, is asked to choose eight audio recordings (usually, but not always, music), a book and a luxury item that they would like to take if they were to be cast away on a desert island. The castaway often has a sentimental reason for their choices, and will discuss the significance of the selection with the presenter.*
SO, flipping the concept round to suit this community, my discussion prompt is: what would be your EIGHT books, ONE musical recording, and ONE luxury item to keep you company as you are castaway? As per the additional books in the original, I'm throwing in a "Complete Works" by an author of your choice (not forcing Shakespeare on everyone!!) and a religious text if you want them as free choices!!
To go first, mine would be: Anthology of Twentieth-Century British and Irish Poetry, edited by Keith Tuna (this would keep me busy and remind me of home/family) The Expendable Man, by Dorothy B Hughes (one of my faves, would not get bored rereading) The Wind in the Willows, by Kenneth Grahame and illustrated by Inga Moore (sentiment) And Then There Were None, by Agatha Christie (one of my favourite authors, again wouldn't tire of rereading!) To The Lighthouse, by Virginia Woolf (never read it, but SO keen to and I believe it's one of her masterpieces!) Unwell Women, by Elinor Cleghorn (to remind me that despite being castaway many have suffered worse fates than I!) Pride and Prejudice, by Jane Austen (I've watched the 1992 BBC series so many times that reading this would be like having Alison Steadman with me on the island! Sentimental and entertainment!) I Who Have Never Known Men, by Jacqueline Harpman (I think rereading this in my new setting would strike new resonances!) I will take the Shakespeare complete works option!!
My music choice would be 'The Lark Ascending', by Ralph Vaughan Williams (nostalgia, love and really could listen to this all day!)
My luxury item would be a king-size patchwork quilt.
Looking forward to seeing the books, recording and luxury choices!!
P.S.: if you fancy a laugh, I do recommend looking at some of the luxury items that people request. You can find lists and lists on Wikipedia. My favourite was someone who requested the entire Victoria & Albert Museum (one of the best/biggest museums in London) which feels like a real cheat code!!