3.67 average · 339 reviews
Click a segment to filter

I don't know if I missed something, but I was just waiting for this book to make sense. In the way that I didn't understand what the intention was.
And maybe part of it is on me, because from the synopsis I thought these people were going to be snowed in together and confronting some hard truths. Instead, it was just a slow, meandering story and of course, their lives "started to unravel" (as per the synopsis), I felt like it didn't happen in any impactful way.
I normally enjoy slow books, but they need to have some intention behind them or something needs to be significant. The book deals with heavy themes, but it feels like it's all a bit obscured from view and I would love to get underneath the surface a bit more. Maybe I was just expecting a bigger emotional impact.
But still I just felt like this book didn't tackle anything new in a significant way, so it just kind of felt like I wasted my time, even though I genuinly enjoyed the reading experience. The prose was also really good, and I did get an emotional connection to most of the main characters (ifykyk).
I think this book would be a good fit for someone looking for more of a "cosy" book that deals with heavier themes. That is not to say that I think this book is cosy, but rather that it reminds me a bit of books that are labeled "cosy" in the narrative pace and structure.


idaquaries commented...
For me, I usually use this as a general guideline if I'm unsure about the rating! But mostly I base it on the vibe (but that matches up to this)
⭐️ - Regret finishing it and it had problematic elements ⭐️⭐️ - Regret finishing it/did not like it ⭐️⭐️⭐️ - I liked it and it was okay, but probably wouldn't pick up another book by this author. It was average. May fit another reader's taste, but not mine. ⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 - Unsure if I would pick up another book by this author, but would if the premise is really interesting or I'm in the mood. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ - I liked it, would recommend it to others and would pick up another book by this author. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 - really good book, but something was just missing to make it perfect. either a book that was really enjoyable, but there was some part of the writing/plot that i didn't like or the quality was really high but i wasn't as imvested as i would be for a 5 star. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ - would read this specific book again and most likely want to reread immediately.
Generally, I don't use .5 ratings and just do whole stars, unless I'm struggling between two ratings. But generally i just think about whether I would want to read something else by that author if I'm unsure if it's a 3 or 4 star book

Like what is the exact criteria for a 5 star book vs a 3 star one😭 😭? I have an idea of how much I like a book but it is simply a problem of representing it in a numerical value, it feels like I have to make a ‘’correct choice’’ so I can truly depict how much I liked it or not.
Maybe I’m just stupid idk but it keeps me up at night, same reason for why I don’t rate movies on letterboxd