ploidia entered a giveaway...
ploidia is interested in reading...

Nicked
M.T. Anderson
ploidia is interested in reading...

The King in Yellow
Robert W. Chambers
ploidia TBR'd a book

The Invisible Man
H.G. Wells
ploidia TBR'd a book

O Vendedor de Passados
José Eduardo Agualusa
ploidia started reading...

Island
Aldous Huxley
ploidia commented on ploidia's update
ploidia DNF'd a book

The Worm Ouroboros
E.R. Eddison
ploidia DNF'd a book

The Worm Ouroboros
E.R. Eddison
ploidia commented on ploidia's update
ploidia started reading...

The Worm Ouroboros
E.R. Eddison
ploidia commented on rilakkuma00's review of Blood Over Bright Haven
I would’ve ate this up if it was a film
ploidia wrote a review...
like "the ones who walk away from omelas", in "blood over bright haven" we are met with an utopic society whose existence depends on a dark secret.
although it is 400 pages, it reads much faster since the writing is very straightforward. too much at times, though. the book is very explicit about its themes, which shows comittment (i respect that), but also tires the reader and takes away a bit of the fun of thinking about the implication of things. we don’t need to think too much here, it's all laid out on the pages.
i also felt there was a lot of talking, specially on the second half. not that that's inherently bad, but narrative and internal dialogue sometimes trumps explicit exchange between characters; this is the beauty of the Art of the Word. scenes that were supposed to be emotional and cathartic got a little lost in the very expositive dialogue.
i liked the ending, although it was positively a bad move from the protagonist; i liked how the narrative took ownership of that. yes, she's selfish as hell. this is how it went for her.
all in all though, i felt this story would benefit from more nuance. it would increase the richness of the world and the stakes too. though this fictionalized version of the US feels kinda correct in some aspects, lol
ps. this is about every colonization ever btw. the indigenous people of all the americas went through that. the people of africa went through that. palestine and so many other countries are going through that right now. it's important to remember the past, acknowledge it, and understand how it influences our lives right now.