

Broad reading broadly. Mom of two. Public servant lurking on aaallll the political drama. I love libraries, accessible public realm that supports dense communities, and bikes 🚲 She/her 🇨🇦
8905 points











3.64 average · 549 reviews
Click a segment to filter
This is the best thing I’ve read since The Fifth Season and I am so fired up about it. Like The Fifth Season, The Spear Cuts Through Water plays with point of view in a highly imaginative and satisfying way. Jimenez uses tense to signal when he has shifted from one time or perspective to another, allowing him to weave together disparate stories before deftly knotting all loose ends together at the conclusion. I love how tapestry and weaving is an explicit theme, especially when the spear is likened to a needle.
Jimenez consistently resists tropes in the telling of his story. I can’t tell you how many times I gasped at an unexpected plot turn, gripping the pages of my book as I eagerly read to see how things might play out. Villains are given especially inventive treatment: some are vanquished at unexpected times, others surprisingly invite our heartfelt sympathy. All of them are gruesome and horrifying in their own way.
By including the Inverted Theatre as an active part of his story, Jimenez signals that he values the role of an audience in the co-creation of art. In this fascinating discussion on the map included in the novel, he writes:
Much of the juice of a novel comes from the reader’s personal interaction with the text—the processing of the words on the page through their own ecosystem. Their associations and biases and triggers and desires. The way they are sitting. The quality of light from the window. Even the minutes they have left before they must leave for work. All of this, and more, act as the acids that digest a work of fiction.
The conclusion of the novel respects the role the audience plays in storytelling in a beautiful way. It is heartwarming and full of love. I’m so happy I got to be a shade in the Inverted Theatre and watch this play unfold.
So rad. Maybe not easy to just casually approach with no context or warning, like I did. A couple things that made it more accessible for me:
🍕Reading one story at a time, like a little personal pan pizza
🎧 Consulting extremely nerdy podcast for additional context/analysis
🙈 Applying copious amounts of eyeball/brain bleach
I had no idea this was Victorian “be gay do crime”! +1 ⭐️ for the amazing Hyde and seek pun.
Intermezzo
Sally Rooney



Don't Let the Forest In
C.G. Drews


Woodworking
Emily St. James


robalir commented...

Yesteryear
Caro Claire Burke


robalir commented...


Sky Daddy
Kate Folk
robalir commented...
Would abolishing DST count as clock blocking?