avatar

IceElf

Fan of all things queer sff and horror, especially messy boys, butch ladies, and weird eldritch beings. She/her | UK-based | 🏳️‍🌈

1308 points

0% overlap
Level 4
My Taste
Lord of the Empty Isles
The Invocations
The Paper Boys
Reading...
The Color of Magic (Discworld, #1; Rincewind, #1)
72%
Prince of Fortune
26%

IceElf commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

1h
  • Preference and why

    Paperback or Hardcover? Why?

    14
    comments 36
    Reply
  • IceElf commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    3h
  • Pop Culture References in books. Yay or Nay?

    I’ve been thinking a bit about pop culture references these last few days, and how they can really ruin a book for me, and I’m just wondering if I’m the only one? Or is this something that’s as universally disliked as stickers on book covers.

    I’m not the most pop-culture savvy person, so half the time I just don’t get the reference and it leaves me feeling like there’s a joke I’m just not getting. And then there are the references that I do recognise but leave me feeling uncomfortable. Harry Potter references are very jarring now - even in books written years ago, they still gives me a moment of pause.

    I’m also aware that I’m a lot more forgiving of older pop culture references, though I suppose those might be better termed cultural references. I’m more likely to be put off by a book referring to insert currently popular singer here than Queen or the Beatles – but what’s the cut off? No one would consider Shakespeare or Austen pop culture (though it was at the time it was written) but why should I give that a pass when I would sigh if someone referenced more modern literature.

    Personally, if we need to know what the main character listens to or watches, then I'd rather the author just make something up. I probably have a better chance of working out what something is from the name and what I know of the character than I do of understanding most modern references.

    So what are your thoughts on pop culture references? Do you love them or hate them? Does your opinion change based on how dated they are or whether you get them?

    14
    comments 35
    Reply
  • IceElf commented on OhMyDio's review of Jane Eyre

    3h
  • Jane Eyre
    OhMyDio
    Feb 23, 2026
    2.5
    Enjoyment: 2.0Quality: 2.5Characters: 3.0Plot: 3.0

    ETA: my review does not contain spoilers, but the comment section does!

    I was pleasantly surprised by how different this was from Wuthering Heights, which is maybe not fair but since they get lumped together all the time I definitely thought they were going to be more similar. And there are definitely fingerprints of each on the other, but generally this was much more enjoyable.

    I am also surprised that this has never been spoiled for me? Once she leaves the school, and even while at the school, I didn't really ever know where this was going.

    If this were a solid two hundred pages shorter I think most of my gripes would fade into more of a "this just isn't for me" and out of "wow, I actively dislike this" but because it's sooooo long winded and overwrought with itself I am firmly in the "but, why?" camp.

    There was a solid portion where I was totally engaged and invested, and when the twists twisted I was entertained. I thought a few times "okay, yea, I get the hype" but when we move into the next plot point it all crumbled away back into just wholly mediocre and annoying.

    I did enjoy that Jane, at times, would stand up for herself - station and gender be damned, but I found it entirely frustrating that a woman with such a strong will and since of justice would ultimately make the choices she did. After spending 400 pages languishing on how she wouldn't compromise on her ideals it 100% felt like that's exactly what she did in the end. She then waxes poetical about how her life is now fulfilled because she's living entirely to serve a man. Big ole barf for me, fam! That shit is not romantic. Every single man in this book is a walking stack of red flags and I genuinely hated every single one of them. While I do appreciate that Jane got to "choose" her marriage, it really felt like there were no options, and so much would be different for her if she had ever met one (1) man who was single and not a whole entire asshole.

    Also, shout out to religious abuse; glad that hasn't changed a jot in 200 years.

    Anyway. I'm rambling. I did not care for this, but it did have it's moments here and there.

    13
    comments 9
    Reply
  • Post from the Pagebound Club forum

    3h
  • Pop Culture References in books. Yay or Nay?

    I’ve been thinking a bit about pop culture references these last few days, and how they can really ruin a book for me, and I’m just wondering if I’m the only one? Or is this something that’s as universally disliked as stickers on book covers.

    I’m not the most pop-culture savvy person, so half the time I just don’t get the reference and it leaves me feeling like there’s a joke I’m just not getting. And then there are the references that I do recognise but leave me feeling uncomfortable. Harry Potter references are very jarring now - even in books written years ago, they still gives me a moment of pause.

    I’m also aware that I’m a lot more forgiving of older pop culture references, though I suppose those might be better termed cultural references. I’m more likely to be put off by a book referring to insert currently popular singer here than Queen or the Beatles – but what’s the cut off? No one would consider Shakespeare or Austen pop culture (though it was at the time it was written) but why should I give that a pass when I would sigh if someone referenced more modern literature.

    Personally, if we need to know what the main character listens to or watches, then I'd rather the author just make something up. I probably have a better chance of working out what something is from the name and what I know of the character than I do of understanding most modern references.

    So what are your thoughts on pop culture references? Do you love them or hate them? Does your opinion change based on how dated they are or whether you get them?

    14
    comments 35
    Reply
  • IceElf commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    5h
  • How to manage time for reading?

    Right now, in my last semester, I have a lot of projects and tests to do, but I really want to read books. How do people with tight schedules and little time manage to read without losing interest or losing track of the story? Or do I just have to accept my fate and read after everything is done? For me, that would take 1–2 months until then.

    25
    comments 28
    Reply
  • IceElf DNF'd a book

    7h
    Apparently, Sir Cameron Needs to Die

    Apparently, Sir Cameron Needs to Die

    Greer Stothers

    0
    0
    Reply

    IceElf commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    9h
  • How do you "cast" the characters in a book?

    I've been wondering how people "cast" the characters in the books they read... I mean... how do you decide what faces they have in your mind? Do you picture actors, people you know, or do you invent new faces, or maybe you imagine cartoons? If the book got a movie adaptation it's easier, but do you stay loyal to that? Personally, I picture a lot of actors and people I know, usually based on the description provided, even if sometimes I change some details (Jace Wayland was always brunette in my head for example 😅). Sometimes I get really proud of my casting, I'm not going to lie ☺️

    11
    comments 23
    Reply
  • IceElf made progress on...

    10h
    The Color of Magic (Discworld, #1; Rincewind, #1)

    The Color of Magic (Discworld, #1; Rincewind, #1)

    Terry Pratchett

    72%
    1
    0
    Reply

    IceElf made progress on...

    21h
    Prince of Fortune

    Prince of Fortune

    Lisa Tirreno

    26%
    0
    0
    Reply

    IceElf made progress on...

    1d
    Apparently, Sir Cameron Needs to Die

    Apparently, Sir Cameron Needs to Die

    Greer Stothers

    58%
    0
    0
    Reply

    IceElf commented on a post

    1d
  • Howl’s Moving Castle (Howl’s Moving Castle, #1)
    Thoughts from 6%

    Can’t believe I’ve never read this, my favorite movie ever. Excited to dive in!! In other news, I appreciate the book is subtly giving context to her stepmothers behavior. Sophie is to naive and kind to see how her stepmother is exploiting her and getting rid of her other daughters.

    24
    comments 9
    Reply
  • IceElf wrote a review...

    1d
  • Howl’s Moving Castle (Howl’s Moving Castle, #1)
    IceElf
    Feb 22, 2026
    4.0
    Enjoyment: 4.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 5.0Plot: 4.0
    🔥
    🏰
    👵

    I really wish I'd read this book as a child! I'd have loved it then, I'm sure! And I still very much enjoyed it now. I'm a big fan of Sophie's practicality and Howl's dramatics!

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • IceElf wrote a review...

    1d
  • The Faithless (Magic of the Lost, #2)
    IceElf
    Feb 22, 2026
    4.0
    Enjoyment: 4.0Quality: 5.0Characters: 4.5Plot: 4.0
    👑
    🌹
    ⚔️

    The Faithless follows on from where the Unbroken left off, with Qazal trying to establish itself as an independent nation.

    Together with Aranen and Ghadin, Touraine travels to negotiate a new relationship with Balladaire—and with Luca, who is herself in a perilous position as she attempts to take the throne from her uncle, who has been acting as regent for several years. The plot is mostly focused on Luca’s search for Balladaire’s lost magic, and Touraine’s attempts to understand her own magic, whilst both are mixed up in the political wrangling that has resulted from Luca’s ‘loss’ of Balladaire. Her uncle – the regent – considers her incompetent and wants the throne for his own – and plans to retake Qazal once he has done so.

    Neither Luca nor Touraine are all that good at making the correct decisions, but it is somehow entertaining to watch them fumble from one bad decision to the next, while also trying to ignore their feelings for one another – the relationship is still incredibly unhealthy, but somehow I still found myself rooting for them to sort themselves out.

    (Although, a little disappointed that the teased threesome with Sabine never emerged. I did enjoy Sabine a lot though, she’s kind of ridiculous in her flamboyance, but I love her)

    We also gain new perspectives: Touraine’s old lover and friend Pruett returns to her own homeland in an attempt to gain allies for Qazal, and the daughter of one of Luca’s old guards becomes entangled with a group striving for revolution. This latter thread was interestingly done, since the rebels are also racist and thus also far from ideal for continuing relations between Qazal and Balladaire.

    Overall, I think the book continues to tackle the reality of colonialism, including the split loyalties that Touraine feels towards Qazal and Balladaire, and the continuing relationship between the two nations. It seems as if things will come to a head in the third book, with Touraine forced to choose between her two homelands.

    If you enjoyed the first, I think you’ll also like this one!

    0
    comments 0
    Reply
  • IceElf commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    1d
  • E.Reads
    Edited
    Reading challenges : How do you keep track?

    What's on the tin, really. If you don't have a social media/youtube, how do you keep track?

    I don't want to go back to social media, but I also struggle to remember my (soft) goals and I kind of miss the social, accountability aspect of them. And cheering other people on with their own challenges.

    I'm thinking of maybe creating a weekly/bi-weekly/monthly post where people can share their progess here on PB but I'm not sure if it's allowed? Give me a peak into your system, pretty pretty please.

    Edit to add : by social media I mean places with short form content and endless scrowling. Ads every two posts, rage bating, AI made, ... I know forums are technically social media but they feel different and I hope you get what I mean here.

    7
    comments 14
    Reply
  • IceElf commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    1d
  • Most-read Authors

    What are your most-read authors?

    I think the three authors from whom i've read the most books are Tahereh Mafi (9 Books), Leigh Bardugo and Jennifer L. Armentrout (both 7 Books). I've also read a lot by the German author Sebastian Fitzek, but i don't know how many of his books i've read. I think at least 9 or 10.

    41
    comments 83
    Reply
  • IceElf commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    1d
  • York bookshop recs!

    I’m headed up to York next weekend for a little city break and I’m wondering if anyone has any recs for bookshops there? (Or any other cute ideas for a relaxing weekend trip)

    14
    comments 13
    Reply
  • IceElf commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    2d
  • Whats that one genre…?

    That one genre that you want so badly to get into but every time you try you hit a brick wall. For example, I have personally tried to read Epic Fantasy many many times, and for some reason every time i try I have never been able to finish a single book. I feel like I love hearing and reading more about epic fantasies than ever actually reading them. However im stubborn and will likely continue to try this genre cause im so sure at least one book or series will be for me.

    30
    comments 48
    Reply