Peony commented on a post


Hi everyone, i was wandering if anyone is interested in an unofficial readalong and i think a good theme is pre golden age. Currently The Moonstone by Wilkie Collins The Woman in white by Wilkie Collins A study in scarlet by Arthur Conan Doyle Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle Thirty nine steps by John Buchan Trents last case by EC Bentley
please vote below remember its non compulsory its just some fun. voting ends on June 15 so we can begin July 1 and finish August 31
Peony commented on a post
Wow! Was REALLY not expecting that ending!!! Complex writing and a truly intriguing mystery murder plot. Full review forthcoming.
Post from the British and Irish Crime Classics forum


Hi everyone, i was wandering if anyone is interested in an unofficial readalong and i think a good theme is pre golden age. Currently The Moonstone by Wilkie Collins The Woman in white by Wilkie Collins A study in scarlet by Arthur Conan Doyle Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle Thirty nine steps by John Buchan Trents last case by EC Bentley
please vote below remember its non compulsory its just some fun. voting ends on June 15 so we can begin July 1 and finish August 31
Peony commented on a post
Peony commented on a post
Peony wrote a review...
An interesting murder mystery as, it has a narrator who solves the crime but is definitely not a normal investigator and a cast of characters who are so infuriating in their privilage. i still very much enjoyed it though, the narrator wasnt annoying and the mystery was pleasant. i also liked that most of case was detailed in the coroners inquiry. Non traditional with a sidequest on the evils of fascism. I think this was a solid mystery and an interesting exploration of a certain social class who were too judgemental for everyone but themselves.
Post from the Not to Be Taken: A Puzzle in Poison forum
Post from the Not to Be Taken: A Puzzle in Poison forum
Post from the Not to Be Taken: A Puzzle in Poison forum
All the characters are so full of themselves and i also love that the "detective" is someone who is not an actual investigator he is just a bystander
Peony finished a book

Not to Be Taken: A Puzzle in Poison
Anthony Berkeley
Peony commented on a post
Very interesting magic system and law. Love the elements of history in this though. Makes it feel like an actual historical narrative.
Peony earned a badge

Summer 2026 Readalong
Read at least 1 book in the Summer 2026 Readalong.
Peony commented on Peony's review of The Poisoned Chocolates Case
what a charming novel. quite untraditional but perfect in its unique way. i liked the many different investiagtor conclusions it was like 6 different drawing room endings. i particualry liked the writing style of the author and cant wait to read more. i dont like the two alternate endings by later authors provided in my edition though they were quite uneccesary.
Peony wrote a review...
what a charming novel. quite untraditional but perfect in its unique way. i liked the many different investiagtor conclusions it was like 6 different drawing room endings. i particualry liked the writing style of the author and cant wait to read more. i dont like the two alternate endings by later authors provided in my edition though they were quite uneccesary.
Post from the The Poisoned Chocolates Case forum
Post from the The Poisoned Chocolates Case forum
the writing style is just amazing and so well done and also hilarious at the same time
Peony finished a book

The Poisoned Chocolates Case
Anthony Berkeley
Peony commented on a post


I saw a post on the main Pagebound Club forum a few weeks ago that was asking about everyone's least favourite genre tropes. To flip that on it's head, I'd love to ask what everyone's most favourite mystery/crime tropes are?
Peony commented on Peony's update
Peony finished a book

When We Lost Our Heads
Heather O'Neill