avatar
Pagebound Royalty Badge

Peony

Loves murder mysteries and has a passion for translated fiction. Pro Tomato 🍅 🇦🇺 Will read other genres through. Loves cats. 🐈‍⬛

23991 points

0% overlap
Cherry Blossom Festival 2026
Japanese Crime Fiction
British and Irish Crime Classics
Universe Quest: Discworld
Russian Lit 101
Japanese Literary Fiction
Winter 2026 Readalong
Spring 2026 Readalong
Summer 2026 Readalong
Pagebound RoyaltyDia de los Muertos 2025Mardi Gras + Carnival 2026
My Taste
Cursed Bunny
And Then There Were None
Death on Gokumon Island
The Decagon House Murders
All Creatures Great and Small (All Creatures Great and Small, #1-2)
Reading...
Emily Wilde's Encyclopaedia of Faeries
5%
The Only Good Indians
58%

October 2026

The Only Good Indians

3.70 average  ·  180 reviews

Click a segment to filter



  • Welcome !!

    Hi everyone! If you don’t know me already I am Peony and the creator of this quest. Japanese crime fiction has been a love of mine for a few years now and I hope that this quest helps other people discover this wonderful genre. I have a mix of murder mysteries and thrillers in this quest so I hope there is a little bit for everyone. Will write a big break down of book genres and timelines for Japanese come writing soon.

    130
    35
  • Book Criteria

    Hi i just wanted to write to say why books have been chosen and the criteria to add more books.

    1. The Author was of British or Irish nationality.
    2. If the author was not, they were a member of the detection club and wrote the books in English and lived in either Britain or Ireland permanently, while the books were written .
    3. The books were either written in the Golden age of Crime fiction 20s to 30s or were of historical/literary signficance before and after those years. I don't want to go later than 1960, while currently the book that is newest i believe was from 1952.
    4. They have to be in print and accessible. Unfortunately a lot of books are not in print so i tried to stick to books, that i know are in print and you can at least buy them online, (i have tried my best with this and hopefully most people are able to access books on this list).

    Why certain books were chosen over others? A great part of classic crime novels are that they are pretty self contained and you don't need to read the precdeding books in the series. Generally i have stuck with the first book in the series and then the most important /popular work by that author. To do this i looked for how popular a book was at the time, the crime writers association list of best crime novels from 1990 and looking at detection club members books that were most popular/still in print.

    I have also tried to stick with max 3 books per author, an exception to this was Agatha Christie in which this list has 5 of her works. Which are considered her most renowned/the first Miss Marple.

    I would love to get suggestions for books if they meet the criteria above so that this list does occaisionally have add ons. So if you have any more questions/suggestions for books please write in the comments of this post.

    36
    18
  • What introduced you to Pratchett?

    I started with good omens, the tv show was coming out and I read the book. Loved it then it, was then a toss up between trying Pratchett or Gaiman and it turns out I chose correctly!!

    15
    23

  • avatar
    Pagebound Royalty Badge

    Peony commented...

    As someone who dosent read Romantasy and just read “tattooing women without their consent’ is a trope. Blink three times if you need help!

  • A romantasy ick that’s just occurred to me.

    What the hell is with these men tattooing women without their consent!?

    I’ve lost count of the amount of books with randomly appearing tattoos in them now, usually associated with the fated mates trope and I’m like !?!?!?!? How are you not mad about this?

    37
    85
  • avatar
    Pagebound Royalty Badge

    Peony commented...

    I don’t know and I will not be counting them. Because then I might need to rethink some life choices.

  • Number of physically owned books?

    Hi everyone! 👋 I’m curious: How many books do you physically own? (mainly asking about physical books because my primary concern is shelf space) Are you happy with this number? Do you do regular unhauls to maintain/get closer to your ideal number? And on a related note, what percentage of those books have you actually read? 😉

    I have about 300 books on my shelves, and I’ve currently read about 40% of them, which I’m hoping to remedy this year! (either by reading more of them or unhauling the ones I’m no longer interested in)

    38
    68
  • avatar
    Pagebound Royalty Badge

    Peony commented...

    A Belgian man who is supposed to be retired, with his dumb as hell British bestie try and work out why people die every time they go on holiday.

  • Describe your favourite book in the worst way possible.

    Guys let's play a game 😭. Describe your favourite book or one of your favourite books as badly as possible and let others guess it. I’ll go first!

    Summer camp turns out to be mandatory military training for neglected children and in this said summer camp, A child is blamed for a crime he didn’t commit and must road-trip across America to prove it.

    Can't wait to guess your books!

    100
    390