one_crazy_eliott's avatar

one_crazy_eliott

he/him | I'm a MG book lover and I especially love books with LGBTQ+ and neurodivergent rep. I'm trying to branch out a bit more, but my favorite genres are realistic fiction and magical realism. :)

10830 points

0% overlap
Top Contributor
LGBTQ+ Middle Grade
Level 8
My Taste
The Mysterious Benedict Society (The Mysterious Benedict Society, #1)
Front Desk (Front Desk, #1)
The Guncle (The Guncle, #1)
Project Hail Mary
They Threw Us Away (The Teddies Saga, #1)
Reading...
The Library BookTomorrow Will Be Different: Love, Loss, and the Fight for Trans EqualityDouble O Stephen and the Ghostly RealmThe Girl and the Ghost

one_crazy_eliott wrote a review...

11h
  • Carmilla
    one_crazy_eliott
    Aug 24, 2025
    3.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    Carmilla Overall Rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ (3/5) or 6.28/10 overall Characters - 5.5 The characters weren't particularly multi-dimensional but since this is pretty short and relatively fast-paced, I didn't really mind. I think having the character be fairly generalized also helped this feel a bit more timeless. Atmosphere - 7 The atmosphere was good and very spooky. I think even readers who didn't know much about the story going in would be able to pick up that something mysterious and dangerous was going on here. Writing - 7 Honestly, the writing held up for being about 150 years old. It was much easier to read than you might have expected. I definitely felt my brain having to work to provide an equivalent modern-day word or phrase a few times but I kind of liked doing that since it made me more confident that I was comprehending what was happening. :) Plot - 6 I will say that the plot isn't super interesting but today's fast-paced standard but I will give it credit for being the first of its kind. While I did find myself drawing parallels to Dracula, Carmilla was written before Dracula was so, if anything, Dracula was the one copying the plot of Carmilla. Intrigue - 6.5 I was decently intrigued by this book. I think because it was obvious that Carmilla was a vampire from the start that lessened a bit of the "what's going to happen??" feeling, but that didn't stop me from still wanting to know what Carmilla was going to do to Laura. Logic - 6 This was reasonably logical. Idk what else to say lol 🤷‍♂️ Enjoyment - 6 This was a pretty enjoyable read. I do think I would've liked to have seen things wrap up a little more but I was still relatively satisfied. Definitely a must-read of classic LGBTQ+ literature and vampire literature alike. :)

    1
    comments 0
    Reply
  • one_crazy_eliott commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    12h
  • "does it have smut/spice?"—and why this question annoys me

    I might be shitting on a lot of readers and okay, anyone can read whatever they want to. Who cares. But here's my qualm with it, the question annoys me so so so much whenever I see it below marketing posts and reviews. Why is this question so important? Is that the sole marker of your reading list? Not that there's anything wrong with spice but there are specific genres that are catered to your reading preferences so why would you ask that below random books? Especially IF IT'S YA??? THEY ARE TEENAGERS. WHY WOULD YOU WANT TO READ ABOUT MINORS HAVING SEX??? THAT'S WEIRD. (I'M LOOKING AT YOU SARAH J MASS) It gives this narrative that books need to be spicy to have good romance and that's just not true. It's because of this mindset that so many authors who have genuinely good stories with potential feel to need to have smut addded to them UNNECESSARILY because otherwise a lot of readers won't pick it up. THERE IS A WHOLE GENRE FOR YOU — EROTICA. IT'S CALLED EROTICA. Can you please pick up erotica instead of asking that question under posts about random books. PLEASE. LET ME ENJOY MY NON SMUT ROMANCE/THRILLER/FANTASY/MYTERY IN PEACE. I'M BEGGIN YOU Edit: A good example of this was people asking "does it have smut" under a post about The Last Tiger by The Riew Siblings. They'd clearly mentioned in the post that the book was a fictional retelling of their grandparents' very real story AND on top of that it was YA. And then you ask. Does. It. Have. Smut??? Be for real right now please 😭

    26
    comments 40
    Reply
  • one_crazy_eliott commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    14h
  • Take on self-help books?

    I’ve definitely read some that I didn’t like at all, but there are also a few that I’ve really connected with. I don’t see them as something that’s going to fix my life, but I do like having them around for when I need a little perspective or motivation. Sometimes I see TikToks making fun of these books and it makes me wonder if it’s weird that I actually enjoy some of them. Like I know it's not for everyone but it kinda makes me feel that these books are a "scam" by the way they're reacting.

    9
    comments 27
    Reply
  • one_crazy_eliott commented on a post

    15h
  • Gideon the Ninth (The Locked Tomb, #1)
    Thoughts from 13% (page 56)

    Do NOT like the writing of this.

    8
    comments 16
    Reply
  • one_crazy_eliott commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    15h
  • Reviewing YA books

    I am curious if people take the fact a book is ya or middle grade into account when reviewing books. I am not the target audience of ya, but still read it at times. I always try to take a second and go "what would teenage me think of this?" Before finalizing a review on a public forum. There is definitely stuff that I don't enjoy as much at 28 that I didn't mind at all at 16, so I try to account for that in my ratings. My logic is I don't want a teenager to not read a book they would enjoy because I grew out of some aspects of it, if that makes sense. Does anyone else do this, or do you always review a book based on who you are when you read it, even if you aren't the target audience?

    14
    comments 43
    Reply
  • one_crazy_eliott commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    1d
  • Why do you join a quest?

    With all the new quests dropping today (including the first installment of the genre starter packs), I'm curious. What inspires you to join a quest? Do you have certain criteria or do you just think "oooh pretty badge, must join"? 😂 For me, I've set the limit that I must have a genuine interest in at least 5 books in a quest to join it. That way I know I can at least obtain the lowest tier of badge, doesn't matter if it's a side or main quest. I feel like if there are less than 5 books in the quest that I want to/have read, it's probably not for me anyway. What do you think? Do you have a similar thought process or do you think about the quests completely differently?

    31
    comments 39
    Reply
  • one_crazy_eliott commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    1d
  • Bookish questions because I'm a nosy person

    Hello again!🤗 Today I was thinking about how excited I am to do a year wrap up when the year ends (obviously 🤣) and I want to ask you the same questions I asked my self, so here they go: 1- What's your favorite book of the year so far? 2- Which book/books you were so hyped for but ended up being a disappointment? 3- Which new author/authors you found out this year and feel in love with? 4- Which book/books you thought you would give 1 star but ended up giving 4/5 stars? 5- How close are you to complete your reading challenge (if you have one)? I hope everyone has a nice weekend and thank you for letting be your very curious book friend 🤣🫶

    31
    comments 90
    Reply
  • one_crazy_eliott commented on seema's update

    seema earned a badge

    2d
    Level 11

    Level 11

    22000 points

    98
    103
    Reply

    Post from the Carmilla forum

    2d
  • Carmilla
    Thoughts from 61% (page 92)
    spoilers

    View spoiler

    3
    comments 0
    Reply
  • one_crazy_eliott commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum

    2d
  • Why do you join a quest?

    With all the new quests dropping today (including the first installment of the genre starter packs), I'm curious. What inspires you to join a quest? Do you have certain criteria or do you just think "oooh pretty badge, must join"? 😂 For me, I've set the limit that I must have a genuine interest in at least 5 books in a quest to join it. That way I know I can at least obtain the lowest tier of badge, doesn't matter if it's a side or main quest. I feel like if there are less than 5 books in the quest that I want to/have read, it's probably not for me anyway. What do you think? Do you have a similar thought process or do you think about the quests completely differently?

    31
    comments 39
    Reply
  • Post from the Pagebound Club forum

    2d
  • Why do you join a quest?

    With all the new quests dropping today (including the first installment of the genre starter packs), I'm curious. What inspires you to join a quest? Do you have certain criteria or do you just think "oooh pretty badge, must join"? 😂 For me, I've set the limit that I must have a genuine interest in at least 5 books in a quest to join it. That way I know I can at least obtain the lowest tier of badge, doesn't matter if it's a side or main quest. I feel like if there are less than 5 books in the quest that I want to/have read, it's probably not for me anyway. What do you think? Do you have a similar thought process or do you think about the quests completely differently?

    31
    comments 39
    Reply
  • one_crazy_eliott wants to read...

    2d
    Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking

    Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking

    Malcolm Gladwell

    3
    0
    Reply

    one_crazy_eliott commented on kathytrithardt's review of Puzzleheart

    2d
  • Puzzleheart
    kathytrithardt
    Aug 22, 2025
    4.0
    Enjoyment: 4.5Quality: 4.0Characters: 4.5Plot: 4.0
    🏠
    🧩
    🥰

    This was adorable, adventurous, and had a lot to say about various types of relationship. I really enjoyed it.

    4
    comments 1
    Reply
  • Post from the The Library Book forum

    2d
  • The Library Book
    True Crime Starter Pack Vol 1

    So excited to see this make it in the 1st True Crime quest!!! :D

    3
    comments 0
    Reply