avatar

saturnia

25 | uk/nl | they/them | metalhead | data nerd Ⓐ true crime, history, social justice/feminism and gothic/horror enjoyer. slowly reading more classics. big mood reader. |{formerly ghxstfolk}|

21439 points

0% overlap
Sapphic Vampires
Forgive Us Our Trespasses: Religious Horror
Botanical Horror
My Taste
The Book Thief
Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body and Primitive Accumulation
Empire of Pain: The Secret History of the Sackler Dynasty
My Darling Dreadful Thing
Reading...
Sorrowland
10%
Into the Drowning Deep
18%
The Aeneid
22%
The Only Good Indians
63%
Nobody's Girl: A Memoir of Surviving Abuse and Fighting for Justice
40%
The Great Post Office Scandal: The story of the fight to expose a multimillion pound IT disaster which put innocent people in jail
51%
The Count of Monte Cristo
59%
Invisible Women: Data Bias in a World Designed for Men
53%
Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body and Primitive Accumulation
58%


3.01 average  ·  241 reviews

Click a segment to filter

  • Oct 02, 2026
    The Princess Trap
    The Princess TrapTalia Hibbert
    1.0
    Enjoyment: Quality: Characters: Plot:

    let's start with the superficial problems first, shall we. the writing style feels like a USian's idea of what a stereotypical Brit talks like and it was irritating from the start, especially the way "bloody" was used so liberally, and it never got better. I also don't know if it's just me, but I don't understand why Ruben has to be from a fictional country that's essentially Denmark-But-Not-Denmark when it's set in the modern world and the language they speak is literally Danish. it's referenced to being in/around Scandinavia and every time details about it just pulled me out of the whole story. if the book was actually good I could have moved past these points, but it wasn't, so I couldn't.

    I don't like instalove or instalust stories to start with, but even as their "relationship" developed beyond the initial setup I never felt any chemistry between them beyond Ruben's somewhat-innate urge to fuck Cherry. all of the characters, including the protagonists felt like they had one (1) personality trait each, and nothing more. Harald and Sophy were both cartoon villains and the other side characters were as equally one-dimensional and only served to be plot devices and drag the story along. the domestic/child violence plot came out of left field and felt like a poor attempt to shoehorn another serious topic into the story, with an absolute piss-poor conclusion to top it off.

    as much as I love a diverse cast of characters, having a fat Black woman be the protagonist of your romance story does not feel particularly diverse when she still falls into the trap of romance character stereotypes. even with bisexual protagonists, it felt like an afterthought. bi erasure is real and I don't think bi people have to date people of the same gender to be seen as "valid" but bisexuality here is never actually represented in any proper way. it's an offhand comment which sure, it doesn't need to be a big coming out deal, but when there's an entire scandal based around Ruben being bisexual, having said scandal only ever vaguely referenced or danced around and it only ever being implied he slept with a man, there needs to be more. for so much of the marketing to rely on having bi protagonists there was little actual queer representation beyond the few sentences that feel crammed in. having both Cherry and Ruben be bisexual gives even more chance to have sexuality be explored as a theme in this book, but it's so painfully straight and bisexuality so carelessly tossed in as a diversity marker that I literally forgot Cherry was even bi until I was writing this review.

    beyond the fact Cherry is not the typical romance protagonist (and I like that), this fell into the pitfall of every single thing I dislike about (modern) romance. Ruben is supposed to be Not Like Other Men when he is in fact, Just Another Man and aside from her appearance, Cherry falls into the "hot bombshell everyone wants to fuck" stereotype it's just not original. the sex scenes also rushed into kink stuff without proper consent/negotiations (no, asking what someone's safeword is as you start engaging in kink stuff does not count) or any aftercare so it just felt uncomfortable. is the "man pines after woman instead of the othee way round" plot that subversive when he ekes submission out of her in the bedroom? not for me.

    overall, this book was a mess. it wanted to be a steamy fake-relationship romance while trying to tackle sensitive topics like child/domestic abuse and racism, leaving a hastily added mishmash of clichés and poorly addressed real-life issues behind.

    17


  • Calibre and AI :(

    just posting here as I know a lot of us use Calibre for organising ebooks! if people aren't already aware, it looks like Calibre is sadly going down the AI slop route:

    New features

    Allow generating book covers using AI with different cover styles such as romance, sci-fi, pulp fiction etc.
    
    To use it select a book and click Edit metadata and then the "AI Generate" button. Note that you will have to configure an image generating AI provider the first time you use this feature.
    

    at the moment, there is a setting in the "advanced settings" page that allows you to turn off the AI features which looks to be useful at least. a friend also just made me aware of a non-AI slop fork of Calibre that looks to be in the works 🔗here, so I'm looking forward to trying it when it releases properly! 👀 if anyone has any alternatives, feel free to drop them below too!

    55
    11

  • avatar

    saturnia commented...

    100% agree! you can't "separate the art from the artist" when the artist is still alive and actively profiting off said art - not to mention the fact that jkr actively wove various bigotries, including transphobia, into the series itself, so those who say there's nothing wrong with the HP universe beyond its creator are also very wrong in that aspect too

  • Trans lives matter more than HP

    I’m just looking for more people to follow who hold this belief. I recently made a comment on here on a quest that we as a community shouldn’t platform HP because of the harm JKR is doing to trans people like me and I’m being called a book burner for this when I never called for book burning. JKR enacts politically violence and has assaulted a trans woman (took upskirt photos of this woman) and I’m tired of being told I’m a book burner when I ask people not to platform for that. Her money she earns from HP is being used to hurt trans people like me. I just need other people to follow on here with the same beliefs because I’m tired and feeling ostracized in the book community for believing Trans lives matter more than a stupid book

    429
    254