More Lovers, More Fun
Unfortunately, I do love a poly romance.
MMF, FFM, MMM, FFF, MMFM, MMFF, monsters, aliens, whoever wants to join in on the hot & sexy fun…
Enthusiastically accepting recs!
created by alexz
last updated April, 2026
Comments
Game On by Navessa Allen? Although the men do not do more than kiss on page, Tyler certainly thinks about doing more. 👀
my absolute favorite trope is why choose because WHY should they have to choose??? it all started with teen wolf, stiles x Derek and stiles x Lydia, like why should stiles have to choose between Derek and Lydia, why can’t he have both???? AHHHHHHH
omg. STEREK! What a throwback! I was never the biggest fan of Lydia but I agree - why choose? Let him have them both.
i love lists like this because they really help me find my people 🙂↕️
alexzOP
one of us! one of us!
alexzOP
How did everyone let me forget the absolute masterpiece of the poly genre that is Pounded by Produce! The pro-tomato contingent has let me down… 🤭
UNFORTUNATELY?????????? there is nothing unfortunate about polyam romance!!
omg i’m here i’m sat im ready!! also if monsters are on the table: deceived by the gargoyles, entranced by the basilisks both by lillian lark
Love Lillian Lark her writing, they're spicy but also well-rounded 👌.
Oh I love this list! I can recommend Losers by Harley Laroux, The Perfect Fit by Sadie Kincaid and Gifting Me To His Best Friend by Katee Robert
alexzOP
TY!
I second losers!!!
Third losers 🤭 (on a mission to get everyone to read it 😂), but both of those are 👌 exquisite taste 🙌.
4th! I dunno what happened...but it changed me.
Lemme just swing by and recommend The Chosen One series by Macy Blake. 1 human, 8 mates. It's MMMMMMMM.
someone said my name 
Yesss!!! I haven’t read a lot of poly romances but I’m ready!!!
Whoah, the veggie book is one????? MULTIPLE VEGETABLES???? 🥗
you gotta read the veggie tales one and no that isn’t a typo 🙂↕️
alexzOP
100%. a highlight of the list.
….I am not ready for object romances. 😆 Jay just got me interested a little bit in monster romances. One step at a time.
we will be here when you’re ready 🙂↕️
alexzOP
yup. multiple veggies. cuke and tomato.
My reaction exactly
Some new ones on here I didn't know about yet 👀✍️ Poly romances have me too 🤭. Some recs, Sea of Ruin by Pam Godwin, Stolen by the Wolves by Lyx Robinson (this one is omegaverse and multiple books and slow slow, lot of plot).
alexzOP
TY!
Might I suggest iron widow by xiran jay zhao! Second book doesn't focus as much on the poly relationship, but it's still a great read
oh yes I second Iron Widow 🙂↕️
If you’re into a little more taboo, there’s Graves and the Gallows Hill series both by Katelyn Taylor, if you want less taboo but still hot as heck, The Never King series fits, if you want not-so-human there’s Squeak by Vera Valentine, and if you want trash shifter romance I’ve got Psycho Shifters by Jasmine Mas for ya!!
alexzOP
Thanks for the recs Erin!
Marie Mistry books as a rec, personally enjoy the fifth nicniven series that starts with “Through the Faerie Gate”
alexzOP
tysm!
HOW DO I HAVE 0% OVERLAP?!?!?!?
More Than Blood (Blood #1) by Brea Alepoú Bound to Two Bears (Bear Mountain #1) by Kelex Kelex Rerouting River by D. Dove Alpha Bait: Three Werewolves for Dylan by D.J. Heart How Did You Survive Without Us? (Irish Roulette, #1) by Ki Brightly (the entire series) Feral Woods by M.C. Roth Bro Split (More Than Friends, #2)by K.M. Neuhold Unwrapping Chase: An MMX Holiday Alien Romance (Planetary Alliance) by Mars Quinn Rough Heat by Marina Vivancos Aquaculture Affair (The Sea Monster's Mate, #2) by Delaney Rain Gael's Favorite: An MMM Paranormal Romance by Jennifer Cody Ours (Mating Run #5) by Leo Rivers Gambler's Conceit (Calamity City Mafia #1) by Adara Wolf Not So Thanks in Advance (Warts & Claws Inc. #3) by Clio Evans Forced (Alien Clutch, #1) by D. Dove (the entire series) Starting Over: Two Werewolves for Peter by D.J. Heart Alpha Unleashed: Two Werewolves for Sebastian by D.J. Heart The Aliens' Mate by Delaney Rain Worshipped by the Wolves by Kelly Lord Two Dragons, One Mate (The Last Mortals #2) by Silvana Falcon Omega (Evan's Alphas, #1) by D.J. Heart Problems (Ruthless Daddies 2, #1) by Brea Alepoú Stalk Me by Kaitlyn Ash The Thorn Triad: Taken By The Alphas by D.J. Heart The Alpha Pack by D.J. Heart Double Trouble: Two Werewolves for Brian by D.J. Heart Only for Tonight (Dark Desires #0.5) by Kali Noir Smaller Is Better by D.J. Heart The Family Pet by Ki Brightly Finding Home: Claimed by the Vampire Alpha by D.J. Heart Enter the Multi-Vers (The Villainous Things, #4) by C. Rochelle Crash Landing (Quads of Alpha S #1) by Kelex Kelex The Shapeshifter's Secretary (Charmed Away Temp Agency #3) by Amy Padilla Ours (Young, Dumb, and Full of Bad Decisions, #1) by Dominic N. Ashen Bad Blood (The Godbearer, #1) by L.C. Davis
Death's Bloom (Monsters & Mayhem) by Lily Mayne ( iirc the demon possess one of them when he gets involved in smexy time so I don't know if it counts)
alexzOP
i shall add these missing titles thus rectifying your 0% overlap when i have access to a big screen! many thanks for your recs Sean!
👍
alexzOP
you'll have to forgive me for leaving a couple of the more taboo titles off the list. i did vet anything with "blood", "bro" and/or "family" in the title.
If you don't want to put taboo books on the list, you should probably remove Stalk Me by Kaitlyn Ash 😅 it is also vary taboo (Father/Uncle/Son)
alexzOP
ty for the heads up!
Nothing to forgive. your list, your decision
Marked: Three Werewolves for Warren* (Alpha Bait) by D.J. Heart Three Werewolves and one human (one of the werewolves is also a vampire)
I really enjoyed Lola & the Millionaires (reverse harem romance with non-shifter wolves - it's the second book of a series but the first isn't nearly as good as this and also not needed to understand and enjoy this one) and Written (reverse harem romance with a bit of fantasy) - both by Kathryn Moon. Thanks for the list!
