3.91 average · 137 reviews
Click a segment to filter


This is quite possibly my favorite read of this year so far. It hit JUST right in so many ways, I have spent so long writing this review because I want to do it justice, but I cannot even begin to describe how masterful of a wordsmith Rivers Solomon is.
First, the prose is fucking excellent. Completely convoluted and nonsensical in the most beautiful ways. Everything that didn’t make sense also did make sense, every strange turn of phrase or mannerism was so believable because of how these characters are developed that you do not question their absurdity for even a second.
Speaking of the characters, I loved so many of them, but specifically the main character Vern resonated with me deeply. This was my experience with An Unkindness of Ghosts as well, where the main character’s thought processes are so influenced by PTSD and other implied neurodivergences that I can’t help but feel a deep connection despite how different our lives are. I didn’t grow up in a cult, my roots are Native American instead of African American, nor do I relate to many other defining details that I will decline to specify to avoid spoilers, but even with our differences our brains work in such similar ways and that is something I so rarely get to experience in books.
The plot leads you towards figuring out twists/major plot points yourself, but Solomon doesn't focus on trying to completely obfuscate the direction the story is heading, instead they leave you just enough to draw conclusions but not enough to feasibly parse the details or circumstances surrounding them. You can think of things that certainly will end up being true, end up happening, et cetera, but there is so much constantly up in the air that you're left both satisfied in your deductions and still surprised.
There are a LOT of political themes in this book, and while I could see that being overwhelming to some, I think it’s important to recognize that all of these issues are connected. There is no homophobia without misogyny, racism is fundamentally connected to the desire of those in power to stay in power, which is connected to poverty and other various forms of systemic oppression, etc. There is no disconnecting any of it, so I appreciate Rivers Solomon touching on as much as they could and in a way that actually does these issues justice.
An absolute 100% recommendation from me. I literally had to resort to starting a reread after this because I genuinely think any attempted new read would be doomed having to follow this.


The clown emoji is Victor because I hate that man




I just saw that Rivers Solomon made a post on Instagram about a new story they are writing that they are posting as a serial on AO3, and I thought some of y'all would find that interesting!! For those without Instagram or who just don't feel like going to check, here is what they said-
"Here I am not reading the room. Everything, or most everything, is so sad and ridiculous and unright, but for the last few years I’ve had this epic fantasy rattling around in my brain and I wanted to bring the spirit of fanfic to it - posting it serially and chaotically and outside the capitalist publishing apparatus. Yeah, so here is the first chapter of Once I Was Made of Earth on AO3. It’s about how we make stories and how stories make us and what it’s like to find someone just as fucked up by the world as you are and messing it all up because you are human and have more scars than skin. Uhhhh link in profile I guess. The “cover” is just one of my favourite freaky paintings. It’s by James Ward and it’s called the Moment. And isn’t it, uncitizens, isn’t this the moment? https://archiveofourown.org/works/91618061"
I love Rivers Solomon, love AO3, and hate capitalism, so this entire thing is right up my alley. First chapter is up now!!!!


MaddiHunt commented...
eye twitching i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism i hate capitalism

I’m feeling messy. Did yall see someone trademarked the phrase “hot girls read” and asked other businesses to discontinue their use of it 😳 😳
