
Something sci-fi, something new. Something fantasy, something old too. Will ghost a book instead of DNFing bc I’m conflict avoidant.
6009 points



4.21 average · 7 reviews
Click a segment to filter
Bring me all of your dreams, You dreamers, Bring me all of your Heart melodies That I may wrap them In a blue cloud-cloth Away from the too-rough fingers Of the world. –The Dream Keeper, Langston Hughes
In The Serviceberry, Robin Wall Kimmerer gives us a short and sweet glimpse of what life could look like if we loved, trusted, and respected the Earth and one another. Rather than a weighty tome with complex economic theory and equations, we’re given something peaceful, easy, and light. I honor this choice; there are enough books and headlines that devastate and confuse us, giving the impression that a different world is impossible because it’s simply too complicated to enact. We need things that give us hope and care, and, on that, Kimmerer more than delivers.
Reading the words in this book felt like sipping warm broth. It doesn’t cure you right away, but it replenishes you and leaves you feeling loved and tended to. It’s what I needed, someone to remind me that consumption, scarcity, individualism, and fear aren’t the only realities. In fact, they don’t have to be reality at all if I embrace the abundance, flow, sharing, and community that’s already present in the world, that’s been present for ages.
My only criticism, and the reason why I’ve selected 4 stars over 5, is the lack of mention of racism. The reason why the US and its allies are uninterested in indigenous wisdom is racism. Our current way of life and economic systems were created by greedy, violent people who wanted the land that Indigenous peoples had lived on, cultivated and cared for for millennia, and they were willing to kill and dehumanize them to do it. It’s not that they didn’t know or couldn’t perceive a different way of being. They didn’t want to; they chose a system that would enable inequality and instability because it allowed for some to live as gods while the majority struggles for basic survival. I acknowledge that including this discussion would’ve tarnished the peaceful vibes a little bit, but bitters aid in digestion and allow us to enjoy the sweet things more.
Fortunately, perfection is not required for enjoyment, and I’d encourage anyone who is interested in this book to read it and engage with it for what it is: a remembrance as well as a dream keeping of a harmonious future, one where Earth and humanity are in balance, reciprocity and care are core, and abundance is the norm instead of the exception.
If a Christian church and a sacred mountain are intentionally destroyed, one is morally and judicially decried as terror while the other is considered progress. This is what is meant when we assert, “No Justice on Stolen Lands.” Colonizer laws are constructed to benefit settler society.
This book is speaking to something deep down inside of me and helping me integrate and understand things that I was stuck on. I’m not done with the chapter, but it’s very clear that the “US government” has no intention of seeing Indigenous Peoples be sovereign. Granting religious freedom is just lip service and brand management. There’s no real care (not that I was expecting care but more so that it’s just so blatant).
One thing I’ve noticed when it comes to the “US” treatment of marginalized groups: there’s this air of everything being too difficult or too complicated to legislate or manage. We can’t figure out how to protect sacred Indigenous lands or give reparations to the descendants of enslaved people, but we can do so many other complicated things. Taxes, investments, infrastructure management, all complex. Somehow though, they work in affluent neighborhoods but not poor(er) ones. Stuff is only “complicated” when it comes to treating exploited people fairly or with care.
It’s infuriating to read about case after case of the legal system gaslighting the tribes and not doing even the bare minimum to ensure that they’re able to have sovereignty. And the funny thing is, setting aside that they have the legitimate claim to the land, Indigenous Peoples’ religious sovereignty is of benefit to the Earth! They are seeking to protect the land, water systems, plants, animals and humans. There’s a net benefit for all. It’s crazy to me that we do more to defend people’s rights to destroy the planet on a personal whim or for personal gain, but when a group wants to preserve things, there are a billion hoops to jump through.
While reading a book from the Indigenous day event readalong , it got me thinking about how I really don't know much about, well, any ethnic group - not even the ones found where I'm from or where I live now. I would love to have some recs to try to amend that in the future.
Now, I imagine reading this you might first think about non-fiction with some cold, hard facts. However, what I think made me make this post was wanting to feel these identities feel more tangible to me than just some disjointed information, also in a gripping way of its own right. Wait... is this just asking for recs for good representation in fiction, preferably penned by people from the ethnic group they're representing? Hell, I guess so.
Anyhow. Please share if any books come to mind and, if possible, which ethnic group they relate to. Also welcome: tips on how to better find these kinds of books by oneself (so I can stop asking for you guys to do my dirty work). Thanks!
i_cant_decide commented...
A lot of great advice here in the comments. I don’t have specific book recs, but when I read your comment, I thought two things:
1. We’re all part of an ethnic group.
This includes people who are classified as white. Ethnicity can morph and change over time resulting in new ethnic groups, but we all belong to one nonetheless. At the very least, you have knowledge of one ethnic group, your own. And that’s a great jumping off point because as you explore, you can look for ethnic groups that are adjacent to yours or ones that seem completely different. There’s a tie-in with geography. People who live closest to your ethnic group will tend to have more similar customs. It’s also fascinating to think about how the Earth shapes who we are. Are you interested in the ethnic groups of the region in which you currently live, other parts of the world, or where your people are originally from?
I say all this because the term ethnic often gets used to refer to non-white people as in there’s white, and then there’s ethnic. For me, that limits our thinking. When we realize that we’re all our own reference point, it drops the illusion that one group/one people is the absolute reference point. It also enables you to see yourself as part of the web rather than an outside observer.
2. Go beyond the macro labels.
(Mini Disclaimer: This is something to keep in your back pocket, not necessarily try to do in the beginning because it’s easy to get overwhelmed and bogged down. I include it here because it may be helpful to others who are further along in the journey.)
The on-ramp to reading more diversely usually consists of lists, general lists not the Pagebound feature, of authors or books from certain identities like BIPOC or regions (continents, global south, etc.). This is a great start. However, there is risk of flattening the rich ethnic identities underneath those labels. Terms like Indigenous encompass multiple ethnic groups. Furhtermore, it’s easy for the more popular groups within the bigger labels to get visibility. For example, you may be seeking to read Caribbean and get a rec for a book by a Jamaican author. This isn’t bad, but when people think of the Caribbean, Jamaica tends to come to the forefront more than Saint Kitts. Everywhere we go there’s this tendency of certain groups getting more visibility than others.
This isn’t a recommendation to read every book from every ethnic group. That’s not humanly possible. However, keep it in mind because it helps prevent misapplication.
Another example to belabor the point: Nnedi Okorafor is a science fiction author that often pops up on lists of Black Sci-fi writers. She was born in the US to Nigerian parents (Igbo). Because she is Black and often writes about futuristic sci-fi worlds with Black people, her work gets mislabeled as Afrofuturism. She considers her work Africanfuturism because she emphasizes that her writing is tied to African culture as it exists on the continent more so than the experience of it throughout the diaspora. Some may see that as splitting hairs, but it deeply frustrates her. It brings up the question of who gets to name and classify things.
Labels are helpful, but they can also contribute to erasure and cause further harm. For a marginalized person, it can be exhausting when someone comes up to you talking about a different culture from your own because it’s “all the same” to them, even when the person is well-intentioned and doesn’t mean harm (honest mistake). The way to prevent this is precision in our language and maintaining awareness of the flattening that occurs when we engage with cultures outside of our own. Despite the British creating the 13 colonies, Americans today are not British; it’s no longer interchangeable. Even that term American includes erasure. That was the brilliance of Bad Bunny’s half-time show where he says, “God Bless America” and proceeded to name countries that get othered despite being in the Americas, and he still includes the U.S. and Canada.
This is way longer than I intended it to be, so I’m gonna end there. Bad Bunny y’all. lol