isild commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I've been seeing a lot of dislike for certain authors because of their own personal viewpoints. This is to the point where people are getting upset hearing about books by those authors or choose to absolutely, not read anything by them.
What are your thoughts on this?
Personally even if I disagree with the author's takes, I can separate the book from the author; especially if its a work of fiction.
Even its a work of nonfiction, I would still see a reason to read their book, since how then will you understand their viewpoints, they are trying to present, if you are not willing to read it.
However, the only reason I could see not being able to, is if they are literally pushing their viewpoints down onto you in the book themselves, instead of just presenting their thoughts; fiction or nonfiction wise.
I could also see it coming down to the question is an author able to seperate their own views from their story. And yes, I believe they can for sure. The thing is, do they want to. It is their story so they can do whatever they want. And if they do decide to push their own agenda, in their own works of fiction, and you don't agree with their takes, then that is completely understandable.
isild commented on isild's update
isild is interested in reading...

A Long and Speaking Silence
Nghi Vo
isild commented on flowercities's update
isild commented on a post
isild commented on isild's update
isild is re-reading...

Yield Under Great Persuasion
Alexandra Rowland
isild is re-reading...

Yield Under Great Persuasion
Alexandra Rowland
isild commented on isild's update
isild commented on a post
I just wanted to say, this book isn't my favorite of The Singing Hills cycle but there's so much more to discover if you keep with it. Mammoths at the Gates changed the way I think.
Even if you were just so-so on this series I recommend changing gears and reading in chronological order. A Long & Speaking Silence is fantastic.
isild wrote a review...
View spoiler
isild finished a book

The Lion Women of Tehran
Marjan Kamali
Post from the The Lion Women of Tehran forum
After finishing this book, I was reminded of a couple of movies I watched over the last few years and I wanted to share them because they explore similar themes.
The Seed of the Sacred Fig directed by Mohammad Rasoulof. "Investigating judge Iman grapples with paranoia amid political unrest in Tehran. When his gun vanishes, he suspects his wife and daughters, imposing draconian measures that strain family ties as societal rules crumble." If I remember correctly it takes place in 2022.
Cutting Through Rocks directed by Sara Khaki, Mohammad Reza Eyni. "37-year-old Sara Shahverdi, a motorcycle riding, land owning, former midwife-turned-fierce citizen advocate and recent divorcée, just won a landslide local election in her remote Iranian village and everyone has an opinion about it." This one is a documentary. Sara Shahverdi is one of the Iranian lion women.
The works above focus more on women and their fight for their rights, while the one below focus more on the brutality of Iranian prisons and its consequences.
It Was Just an Accident directed by Jafar Panahi. "An unassuming mechanic is reminded of his time in an Iranian prison when he encounters a man he suspects to be his sadistic jailhouse captor."
Have you watched any of the movies I mentioned? Do you have any other recommendations like these ones?
isild commented on a post
Post from the The Lion Women of Tehran forum
isild commented on a post