merrbie commented on merrbie's update
merrbie commented on vulpecula's review of A Murder Most Camp
Ugh, I read this for a challenge and I could feel myself losing brain cells as I read it. Between the incessant pop culture references (including Gilmore Girls, Clueless, Taylor Swift, Gone Girl, and so much more), the indolent billionaire main character 29-year-old with no real personality other than being sarcastic, entitled, and having a passion for film (but also having a ~deep side, of course), and the fact that this book could not stop bringing up tacky stereotypes of gay men that were tired in like...the 2000s, I was about ready to melt into the couch by the time it was over.
Maybe I'm just too cynical for campy shit.
tl;dr Mikey Hartford has never had to work for anything in his life thanks to his family's nationwide very successful grocery food chain. However, when his father interrupts his life of partying, sex, and alcohol by forcing him to work at a rustic and rural summer camp (and make a "positive influence" on the world) lest he lose his trust fund, he is horrified. But not as horrified as when he realizes that a murder happened at this camp 10 years ago...and the murderer may still be around.
I understand that the author was trying to write a satire of a rich nepo baby, but it was very difficult to like, sympathize, or even care about Mikey throughout the book. He just read as super out of touch and entitled, which, yes, is supposed to be his character, but given the damage that entitled billionaires are literally doing in the real world to society and the environment, I literally have zero interest reading about in their "problems." While the narrative tries to justify his decisions and personality with the fact that he uses it as a front to hide from the pain of his mom's early death from cancer, it also lowkey undermines itself whenever Mikey says that his mother "wanted" him to have a trust fund and never face any type of difficulty or obstacle in his life because she grew up poor. It really just read as super out of touch with...well, everything. As he deals with what happens at the camp and tries to solve the murder, Mikey sort of starts to realize that he needs to lower his guard and start living more authentically—but it never feels fully realized tbh.
The narrative also really tried to lean into how Mikey has a huge passion for film-making (mostly by having him quote obsessively from various movies—and also if I had to hear the word "passion" in relation to his film interest one more time, I would have set the book on fire). However, this man apparently quit a position as an assistant producer or something after at most three years because...they didn't take his movie ideas seriously? Like, did he expect to sweep into Hollywood right after graduating and take it by storm without working his way up? Because of this, he had lost his passion and started partying and sexing his way through life. This is "passion"? And after rediscovering his passion at the camp (initially by starting to work on a "documentary" about the murder and later I guess just by realizing he can genuinely care about people), he takes his trust fund and decides to just start a production/film company, which is honestly equally privileged and feels almost like he has learned nothing. How does he think he has the slightest idea how to run a production company when he does not seem to have any sense of work ethic, ability to tolerate frustration, or filter (or, for that matter, work experience in the last five years)?
Also—and really, this is a small point compared to everything else—it started really frustrating me every time Mikey would essentially say something that he didn't mean to say and then mention that he "winces as he says them" or knows that he shouldn't have said it or whatever, because it happened multiple times. Truly, if the book had ended with the murderer killing him to shut him up, I would have preferred it because he was fucking annoying.
Sadly, Mikey was not the only victim of the terrible writing. None of the other characters in this book had any character or development. The main side characters were Mikey's love interest, Jackson, and the group of kids at the camp that he was in charge of, especially his 12-year-old aunt, Annabelle (her mother, who is close to Mikey's age, married Mikey's grandfather because of course). The only thing I could tell you about Jackson is that he is built like a "Greek god," is in med school (and has worked as a lifeguard at the camp for 10 years), and is a golden retriever. Also, did you know that he's hot? That's mentioned a billion times in case you've forgotten. Meanwhile, Annabelle is an outcast at school and hates her parents' age gap, feels out of place, love true crime, and reads thrillers in her spare time. That's it. That's all we know about these side characters.
We know even less about the other kids in the group. They were all essentially interchangeable and...I truly don't have anything to say about them because there was nothing to say. The only one that sort of stood out was Annabelle's roommate, Miranda, and not in a good way. It's because she kept calling Mikey and other people "boo" at the end of almost every sentence. What child does this? Is this a Gen Alpha thing? Is this a rich people thing? JFC.
Although the plot was pretty straightforward and predictable, that wasn't even my main issue with this book given the terrible writing and characters. It was nothing to write home about, though the reliance on information dumping via found diary entries was honestly unrealistic since it literally just spelled everything else for the most part. Tons of telling and not enough (or really, any showing) throughout the book. Jackson and Mikey getting together felt rushed with not enough development on either end, so it was just an insta-love plot and y'all know how much I love those. 🙄
The plot aside, the writing was pretty awful. I already mentioned the author's over-dependence on pop culture references earlier; he truly just throw as many different movie quotes and other references into this book as possible, and it was jarring Every. Single. Time. He also really liked to reuse the same words and phrases throughout the book, such as "passion" as I stated previously, or saying that Mikey had "spent all of his life shield from" XYZ. Finally, and to be honest, the most egregious issue: This book was full of stereotypes of gay men—not just described, but literally spelled out and stated by the characters themselves. For example:
"He’s got none of the qualities that normally cause Mikey’s gaydar to perk up: Sardonic wit, inexplicable defensiveness, a tendency to speak exclusively in abbreviations and/or references. The usual Fire Island personality cocktail.”
Or:
"I thought gays loved karaoke!"
"You're thinking of an entirely different breed of gay," Mikey explains. "Musical theatre gays and/or drag queens. I'm a film school gay with chronically tired gay tendencies—huge difference."
I think this is the author trying to lean into the campy aspect of this book, but it really came across as cringey 2000s offensive humor more than anything else, especially since this book was written and takes place in 2026. At one point, character described himself as being bullied in school because he had an "uncontrollable gay voice." WTF does that mean?! It was so heavy-handed that the characters all came across as gay caricatures rather than real people, which is never good when portraying minorities of any type. @popcornbat commented while I was reading this that if this author wasn't queer himself, it would feel almost like the book was homophobic, which put into words exactly how I felt about it.
So uh, to sum up this 1k-word review, I would recommend it to...people who like reading about billionaire millennials and their problems? Or more seriously, people who don't mind leaning into the camp aspect of this book and can ignore problematic gay stereotypes, cardboard characters, and insta-love romance with zero development. c:
merrbie commented on faatimah-_-'s review of Abaddon's Gate (The Expanse, #3)
View spoiler
merrbie commented on a post
merrbie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I wanna start off by saying im aware PageBound is focusing on genre specific quests rather than universe/author ones and that the existing ones are quite old. This is just for fun and im curious to see what others think 🤭
Hypothetically if you were able to create a universe/author specific quest right now, which would you choose and why? The more niche and unique, the better! And ofcourse as a bonus, what badge should such quest have? :0
Im honestly unsure myself, as some authors have books that are unconnected and won’t fit nicely in a quest and some universes are so small they’ll barely fill up a side quest 😩 looking forward to seeing yall’s ideas ✨
merrbie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
(Trigger warning for light mention of depression acting up)
I’m feeling a massive reading slump on coming because I’ve been reading a lot lately, and it made me think of my usual ways to get out of it.
Typically, I’ll take a book that I feel doesn’t have to be fantastic like a random cozy mystery or some ridiculous (ridiculously fun! - I see you fellow Ice Planet Barbarian fans) spicy books to turn my brain off to and be entertained by.
And there lies my problem. I’m not feeling spicy and I don’t have any cozy mysteries that feel right to me right now. My postpartum depression is acting up big time, and reading was how I stayed out of it. It’s been hard keeping my energy up. I keep feeling my fingers twitch to go towards a book, but then I immediately lose interest. 
I don’t want to go into a slump, so what do you guys do when you feel a slump incoming? Is there a book you go back to? Or do you do what I do and find a book that’s just fun with no expectations on how good the writing will be?
I don’t need recommendations if you don’t have any and just want to comment to share similar experiences or what have you.
merrbie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
So this month, I’m going to try to get the Every Villain is a Hero in Their Own Eyes silver badge, which is 10 books. I’m reading a book that’s going towards that goal atm and have 3 more coming in on Libby that are in the quest as well and that I’m borrowing specifically for this quest ☺️ this is the first time I’ll be reading in a “quest-oriented” way (although I am quite interested in the books anyways)!
So I wanted to ask you guys, are there any specific badges you are hoping to get this month? 🙌 And are there books you’ve read because they are part of a quest, that you maybe wouldn’t have read otherwise? What was your experience with them? ☺️
Wishing everyone a good reading month of July ☀️🫶
merrbie commented on merrbie's review of Assistant to the Villain (Assistant to the Villain, #1)
View spoiler
merrbie commented on vulpecula's update
merrbie commented on merrbie's review of Assistant to the Villain (Assistant to the Villain, #1)
View spoiler
merrbie TBR'd a book

A Mastery of Monsters
Liselle Sambury
merrbie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I normally don’t like to adhere to the strictures of a plan, but for Pagebound, I’ll give it a shot! How successful has this feature been for you all?
merrbie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I wanna start off by saying im aware PageBound is focusing on genre specific quests rather than universe/author ones and that the existing ones are quite old. This is just for fun and im curious to see what others think 🤭
Hypothetically if you were able to create a universe/author specific quest right now, which would you choose and why? The more niche and unique, the better! And ofcourse as a bonus, what badge should such quest have? :0
Im honestly unsure myself, as some authors have books that are unconnected and won’t fit nicely in a quest and some universes are so small they’ll barely fill up a side quest 😩 looking forward to seeing yall’s ideas ✨
merrbie commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Hello, everyone! It's a new month and I'm feeling curious: what are everyone's most anticipated reads for July?
I'm not totally sure what I'll be reading this month (because my mood reader tendencies keep getting on the way 🙄), but I'm pretty sure I'll finally be picking up Among the Burning Flowers by Samantha Shannon during my holiday next week 🤩 I love the Roots of Chaos series and I've been waiting to be in the mood for fantasy again since I reread A Day of Fallen Night in February
I hope July will be an amazing reading month for all of you, here's to hoping for many five-star reads! 🤞