celinewyp wrote a review...
Reread in April 2026
Abhorsen, being the final instalment of a trilogy, cannot be removed from the greater context of said trilogy. Still, Iāll talk about the book itself before moving on to the series as a whole thus far.
Lirael had a whole bunch of buildup, and sadly this book feels like an extension of that same old buildup. Worse, it became less like foundational work and more like stalling. The plot progressed so painfully slow, and itās especially grating since it feels like thereās nothing propelling it forward except the need to get the plot going. A lot happens but so much of it felt needless, making the experience boring and me wanting to ask, āAre we there yet?ā
Things only really get going in the last 25% of the book, perhaps. Suddenly everything is coming together, and thereās a mad rush to get to the end. I donāt see why we had to slog through so much to get here, and it was only midway through the book that there was an infodump on where we were going and why.
Iāll give it to Nix and his worldbuilding and characters. I always end these books wanting to know more about how things work, what happens next, how the characters I like will navigate their futures. Alas, I never get any damn answers.
The Old Kingdom is a world with such unique depth and breadth, but what we get shown is really quite shallow a pool. We get details sure, but a lot of it is vague and we have to take the author at his word at how everything works. Thatās fine, not a dealbreaker. You can still see that thought was put in and time was spent. But if you think too hard, youāll get upset by the lack of answers.
Still, there are some things I really love. For a fantasy, there is some focus on the interactions and conflicts between the magical and nonmagical. We see how the meddling of malicious magical forces can be far-reaching, upending the lives of a group of people and forcing them into becoming refugees and worse.
This applies more to Lirael perhaps but I do appreciate that Nix built the world upon bloodlines and birthright and then asked what happens if someone doesnāt fit that mould destiny chose for them. Iām not sure Iām happy with the answer, but I do think the journey was still worth it.
While Iām looking forward to reading the other, newer books, I think this trilogy has been disappointing to me as an adult. Sabriel was fair, but it went downhill from there precisely because the scope was widened. To me, that will never not be a shame.
Post from the Abhorsen (Abhorsen, #3) forum
celinewyp commented on celinewyp's update
celinewyp finished a book

Abhorsen (Abhorsen, #3)
Garth Nix
celinewyp finished a book

Abhorsen (Abhorsen, #3)
Garth Nix
celinewyp commented on Avalon's update
celinewyp commented on mylesReads's update
mylesReads is re-reading...

The Girl Who Bit Me: A Spicy Sapphic Vampire Romance
Valerie Hunter
celinewyp commented on celinewyp's update
celinewyp TBR'd a book

Finding Famous
Candice Jalili
celinewyp TBR'd a book

Finding Famous
Candice Jalili
celinewyp commented on requiem's update
requiem earned a badge

Pagebound Royalty
Supports Pagebound with a monthly contribution š
celinewyp commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Hello lovely Boundlings! ššø
If your week was a novel, what would the critic blurbs on the cover of the book say about it? Have you had a "This book is overflowing with magic and joy" kind of week? Or was it more of a "a gentle exploration into the mundane nature of everyday life" kind of vibe?
I thought this might be a fun, creative way of taking a moment to reflect on the week before we head into a brand new one. We could even do this each Sunday if we enjoy the conversations! š§š»āāļø
Mine for this week would be: "a quiet novel which speaks tenderly about mental health and the underlying determination required to be well." (Had an anxious week so the novel would likely be some kind of poetic analogy about fear when in reality it was me doing jigsaws and watching a lot of ASMR š)
Let me know what yours would be and whether you'd be interested in this being weekly! š
celinewyp commented on ruiconteur's update
celinewyp commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
Rank your top 5/10 (depending on how many you've read, or if you read less then 5 just tell your favourite so far) from 5th/10th place up. You can also do a top 3 or top 6 or anything between 1 and 10 depending on how many books you've read/how many books you really enjoyed so far. Only ONE book per rank on the scale. That is the hard part. Pick your favourite child.
I'll go first: 7th Tress of the emerald sea - Brandon Sanderson 6th Gallant - V E Schwab 5th A thousand perfect notes - C G Drews 4th Where the dark stands still - A B Poranek
3rd The decagon house murders - Yukito Atsuji
2nd Mistborn: The final empire - Brandon Sanderson
1st First love: essays on friendship - Lilly Dancyger
Loved all of these so much!
Post from the Abhorsen (Abhorsen, #3) forum
celinewyp commented on celinewyp's update
celinewyp commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I've been reading this morning and I have thought of something weird to ask! This is lretty much about reading physical books because ebooks sort of.. save your place already
First, how many of you use bookmarks? How many use something else (dog-earing pages, memorizing the page number (i used to do this when i was reading one book at a time))?
For those of you that use bookmarks, do you take it out when you read and then put it back in to the new spot when you're done reading? Do you move the bookmark ahead to the spot you're aiming to read to? Do you move the bookmark with every page turn? (I've done all these š)
celinewyp commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I've recently read the Dark Profit Saga and The Long Way to a Small Angry Planet and enjoyed both immensely. While completely different genres, what they both have in common is that they are very relevant to the world we live in and have some poignant points to make about our societies. What other fantasy/sci-fi books or series would you recommend that also have this social commentary aspect to them?
Edit: Just to clarify, because perhaps I didn't express myself well (my bad). As some have said, practically any form of writing is in itself social commentary. What I meant however, was the deliberate, intentional kind, as exemplified by the titles I mentioned above.
celinewyp commented on anchorlight's update
anchorlight DNF'd a book

Fractal Noise (Fractalverse, #0)
Christopher Paolini
celinewyp commented on a post from the Pagebound Club forum
I LOVE my streak colour today. I think they last for a week? So I get that amount of time to admire it. Itās this soft lavender and itās definitely my favourite so far (for reference Iām at 124 days).
Whatās your colour right now? What has been your favourite(s)? Please share! š©·ā¤ļøš§”ššš©µšš